Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
“Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church”, with Prof. Christopher Veniamin
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present. Available Units thus far:
Unit 1: Introduction: Holy Scripture, Greek Philosophy, Philo of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 2: Irenaeus of Lyons (Season 3)
Unit 3: Clement the Alexandrian (Season 3)
Unit 4: Origen (Season 3)
Unit 5: Athanasius the Great (Season 3)
Unit 6: The Cappadocian Fathers (Season 3)
Unit 7: Augustine of Hippo (Season 3)
Unit 8: John Chrysostom (Season 3)
Unit 9: Cyril of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 14: Gregory Palamas (Season 1)
Unit 15: John of the Ladder (Season 4)
Unit 16: Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites (Season 2)
MISCELLANEOUS
Members-only: Special Editions (Season 5)
Empirical Dogmatics: The Theology of Fr. John Romanides (Season 6)
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies ; and The Enlargement of the Heart, by Archimandrite Zacharias ; Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022) ; The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016) ; The Transfiguration of Christ in Greek Patristic Literature (2022) ; and Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos, Empirical Dogmatics of the Orthodox Catholic Church: According to the Spoken Teaching of Father John Romanides, Vol. 1 (2012), Vol. 2 (repr. ed. 2020).
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the profound interrelationship between Orthodox theology and the Orthodox Christian life, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos contained therein.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: I wish to express my indebtedness to the spoken and written traditions of Sts Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites, Fr. Zacharias Zacharou, Fr. Kyrill Akon, Fr. Raphael Noica, Fr. Symeon Brüschweiler; Fr. John Romanides, Fr. Pavlos Englezakis, Fr. Georges Florovsky, Prof. Constantine Scouteris, Prof. George Mantzarides, Prof. John Fountoulis, Mtp Hierotheos Vlachos, Mtp Kallistos Ware, and Prof. Panayiotes Chrestou. My presentations have been enriched by all of the above sources. Responsibility however for the content of my presentations is of course mine alone. ©Christopher Veniamin 2024
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
Episode 2: “Philo of Alexandria", Part 1, in "Mystical Theology", with Dr. Christopher Veniamin
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Series: Mystical Theology
Unit 1: Introduction
Episode 2: Philo of Alexandria, Part 1
Introducing the theology and spiritual life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present.
This Episode, "Philo of Alexandria, Part 1", consists of a presentation of Philo, an Alexandrian rabbi of the first century, who was a near contemporary of Christ, and sought to introduce the God of Abraham, of Isaac, and of Jacob, to his pagan intellectual contemporaries.
In this episode, Dr. Christopher Veniamin presents the following aspects of Philo’s contribution in particular: his apophatic (mystical theology), his created–uncreated distinction, the distinction Philo makes between the divine nature and the powers of God, and also the distinctiveness of his Logos theology.
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the interwoven character of theology and the Christian living, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos.
Q&As related to Episode 2 available in The Professor’s Blog.
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: I wish to express my indebtedness to the spoken and written traditions of Sts Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites, Fr. Zacharias Zacharou, Fr. Kyrill Akon, Fr. Raphael Noica, Fr. Symeon Brüschweiler; Fr. John Romanides, Fr. Pavlos Englezakis, Fr. Georges Florovsky, Prof. Constantine Scouteris, Prof. George Mantzarides, Prof. John Fountoulis, Fr. Andrew Louth, and particularly to Mtp Kallistos Ware and Prof. Panayiotes Chrestou: certain sentences and phrases utilized in these presentations are taken directly from my notes of some of their lectures. My presentations have been enriched by all of the above sources, owing to the adoption of certain structures, lists, schemata, and the paraphrasing of themes taken from them. Responsibility for the content of my presentations is of course mine alone. ©Christopher Veniamin 2023
Join the Mount Thabor Academy Podcasts and help us to bring podcasts on Orthodox theology and the spiritual life to the wider community.
If you enjoy our podcast, consider supporting our The Mount Thabor Academy Patreon page, to unlock exclusive, member-only content.
Print Books by MOUNT THABOR PUBLISHING
eBooks Amazon Kindle
Contact us: info@mountthabor.com
Dr. Christopher Veniamin D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Philo of Alexandria's Theology and Influence
Speaker 1So the last time we met we had looked at the language of Scripture , we had talked a little bit and compared to it certain basic elements in Greek philosophy . And today I'd like to begin by presenting to you a couple of aspects from the writings of Philo of Alexandria . In his theology , it seems that Philo , whose years are from around 25 BC to around AD 50 , so he's a contemporary of Christ . It seems that Philo anticipates both the apologists the early apologists and Clement of Alexandria in his synthesis of Scripture and pagan philosophy . He's regarded as representative of the so-called Middle Platonist School , the stoicized form of Platonism which appears in the Roman world from the beginning of the first century BC . Because of the form of his understanding of the soul's ascent towards God . This is how he's usually placed . He's considered as important because of the influence which he exerted on the fathers , particularly of the Alexandrian tradition . So let's say one or two things about him in order to give us a context , some of Philo's distinguishing characteristics . First of all , he was a devout Jew and he's regarded as a lover of allegory . In his interpretation of Scripture On the theological plane , he insisted that God is radically unknowable In a treatise entitled On the Special Laws De Speciallibus Legibus , section 1 , paragraph 43 , following he says the apprehension of me is something more than human nature , yea , even the whole heaven and universe will be able to contain . The apprehension of me is something more than human nature , yea , even the whole heaven and universe will be able to contain . And this empathetic element may also be seen throughout his writings , among other places , in another work called On the Immutability of God , on the Immutability of God , deus Immutabilis . Sit where he says , speaking rhetorically on behalf of Elohim . Do not , however , suppose that the existent , which truly exists , is apprehended by any man , for we have in us no organ by which we can envisage it , neither in sense , for it is imperceptible by sense , nor yet in mind , and here he's referring to the noose . And why should we wonder that the existent cannot be apprehended by men , when even the mind in each of us , the highest part of each of us , is unknown to us ? For who knows the essential nature of the soul , asks Phylo . So there you can see already strong apathetic character to his theology , to the question of the knowledge of God , man's capacity to know God . And in his strong apathetic language we see why many regard him as the father of the mystical tradition .
Speaker 1We've already said before that mystical theology , the mystical tradition for the Orthodox , is not something other than mainstream . It's not a marginal theology , it's not something that's reserved for certain eccentric figures who hover on the margins of the theological tradition . In Christianity , mystical is the only theology that we have , because it's all about encountering God , and the word mystical denotes that initiation , the way by which we come to encounter the great God . Now , phylo's position is very different to that of Platonism , as we had noted when we looked briefly at the Greek philosophical tradition , mainly the Platonist , we said that the Deus Philosopherum , god of the Philosophers , is an impersonal God , and we also noted that that God , the super , personal , absolute , cannot even be aware of the world , because the world is characterized by change , movement , which means coming into being , passing out of existence , which signifies also imperfection . So the Supreme being , which is perfect , according to the philosophers , has to be motionless , has to be a static being . Although it causes everything that moves , it itself has to remain unmoved , and that's why you have , in the tradition of Aristotle , the name the unmoved mover .
Speaker 1Well , with Phylo , who , of course , is aware of all of this , he's aware of the philosophies around him . His position is very different because he believes in a personal God . He believes in the God of Abraham , of Isaac and of Jacob . He believes in a God who reveals himself not in the deity of Aristotle , but in the God who loves his creation . I think it's worth mentioning here that this was an occasion for ridicule in late antiquity , when the Christians appeared in the Greco-Roman world , the Hellenistic world , and began to preach the God of love , because in philosophical terms love meant weakness . That's an oxymoron to say God is love . Love signifies necessity , love signifies need , being incomplete without the object of one's love . We see this even on the human , emotional and psychological level . But philosophically speaking it's about simplicity , divine simplicity and perfection . But Phylo doesn't hesitate to present to his pagan intellectual contemporaries the God of Abraham , isaac and Jacob who loves his creation . And it's Phylo who first introduces the notion of divine darkness in reference to Moses . Phylo is the first to use Moses as a paradigm for the soul's ascent towards God .
Speaker 1In his treatise called On the Migration of Abraham , phylo discerns three stages . The first he calls conversion to pure religion . The second he refers to as self-knowledge , which involves the acquiring of moral purity . And third , knowledge of God . Take a look at a De Migratione Abrahami on the Migration of Abraham , paragraph or section 195 following .
Speaker 1It's also important to note something that Father George Florovsky mentions in volume eight of his complete works , page 87 . On page 87 , father George says Phylo brings a new thought to philosophy , a distinction that was never previously made , but a distinction that will become vital for the Greek and Byzantine fathers , culminating in the thought of St Gregory Palamas . The distinction , of course , to which Father George is referring is that of the created and the uncreated . We said before that in the pagan world , at least the Greco-Roman world of antiquity , nothing came out of nothing . Everything pre-existed , even the amorphous , formless stuff out of which things are made . Even that existed pre-eternally . That was how the pagans thought . But Phylo , because he is basing his philosophy on the Old Testament scriptures , of course has the fundamental distinction of the created and the uncreated . So whereas in Platonism we have an intellectual kinship between the soul and God , in Phylo we find the strict distinction between the created and the uncreated .
Speaker 1Let's take a look at an example . We've already mentioned the fact that for Phylo there is no organ , no instrument , nothing . Even the mind of the human being cannot conceive of God cannot even know the essential nature of the soul . In this treatise , which is called the worst attacks the better quad deterius potiori incendiari solet , the worst attacks the better . In section 18 , this is what Phylo says .
Speaker 1Let us not , then , the pupils of Moses , be any longer at a loss as to how man came to have a conception of the invisible God . How did man come to have a conception of a God who is invisible ? This is what Phylo says by way of explanation , for Moses himself learnt it by a divine communication . It was revealed , revealed to Moses and has taught us how it was . He stated it thus the Creator wrought for the body no soul capable by itself of seeing its maker , but accounting that it would be greatly to the advantage of the thing wrought should it obtain a conception of him who wrought it , since this is what determines happiness and blessedness .
Speaker 1He , god , breathed into him from above of his own deity . This is the Roach , the Benevma of God . He breathed into man of his own deity , the invisible deity , stamped on the invisible soul the impression of itself , to the end , for the purpose that not even the terrestrial region should be without a share in the image of God . This is the image of God , that man was created , capable of containing the Roach Benevma , the Spirit of God . And we know from the epistles of Saint Paul especially , and the scriptures generally , that man is body , soul and spirit . That would constitute normal man , man as he was created to be so , without the spirit of God , because God is the source of life , not surprising that we move towards death , death and corruption . Man , man imitates , falls to the level , shall we say , of beasts , and not only beasts but of demons . So God breathed into Adam from above , of his own deity , in response to Moses' appeal asking God to reveal himself .
Speaker 1Exodus 33 , verses 13 to 23, . Yahweh is made to reply thy zeal . I approve as praiseworthy , but the request cannot fitly be granted to any that are brought into being by creation . Why is this ? Why is this request denied , that the request cannot fitly be granted to any that are brought into being by creation ?
Speaker 1This is where , interestingly , phylo also gives us the seeds of another distinction that becomes very important later on . It's there from the beginning , but it plays a decisive role in the Hazycarse controversies of the 13th and 14th centuries . God , according to phylo , is unknowable in his nature thesis , but he is revealed to us in his powers or his works , his dhnamis , dhnamis . It's interesting the way that phylo talks about these powers , because it's by God's powers that Yahweh reveals himself . And the interesting thing is that although the nature of God , the thesis , divine nature , is unknowable , period , god reveals himself , god makes himself known to his creature by his powers , but his powers themselves are also unknowable . So there's two ways in which we're using the verb to know here . The first is God revealing himself . In other words , the experience of God's revelation is described as knowing . Coming to know God means to receive the revelation of God . God discloses himself , but in that disclosure , although God is revealed , yet he remains hidden . In other words , his powers , by which he reveals himself , are not themselves knowable . They cannot be described because we'll come to that why .
Speaker 1But this is given in another treatise . Actually it's a treatise that we mentioned already on the special laws . It's in the treatise on the special laws , section one this time , paragraphs 45 to 47 , which continues from where Moses asked God to reveal himself . Philo says when Moses heard this , he addressed to him a second petition and said I bow before thy admonitions that I never could have received the vision of thee clearly manifested , but I beseech thee that I may at least see the glory that surrounds thee . So , interestingly , philo is putting in the mouth of Moses a second request , not daring to ask God for a clear vision , but asking that he might at least be granted a vision of the glory that surrounds Yahweh . What is this glory ? What does this mean Actually , philo goes on to say .
Speaker 1He says and by thy glory I understand the powers that keep God around thee , of whom I would feign gain apprehension , for , though hitherto that has escaped me . The thought of it creates in me a mighty longing to have knowledge of them . And to this second petition Yahweh is made to answer the powers which thou seekest to know are discerned not by sight but by mind , even as I , whose they are , am discerned by mind and not by sight . And when I say they are discerned by mind , nus is referring to Nus here significantly , and we'll talk more about the Nus in due course . But he says and when I say they are discerned by mind , I speak not of those things which are now actually apprehended by the Nus , but mean that if these other powers could be apprehended , it would not be by sense , but by Nus at its purest . So the purified Nus , obviously purified by God , the purified Nus is capable of seeing the glory that surrounds Yahweh .
Speaker 1And the glory that surrounds Yahweh , the vision of the glory that surrounds Yahweh , is the vision of the powers that keep God . Now , that sounds at first sight as though these powers might be angels , but the more he talks about them , the less likely that seems , because he goes on here , for example , he says but while in their essence they are beyond your apprehension , they nevertheless present to your sight a sort of impress and copy of their active workings . So here , first of all , let's say that I think we see the seeds of the distinction , found later in the Cappadocian Fathers and in others , between the essence and energies of God . But in pursuing this question further in Philo , we have to ask well , what are these powers ? Does he give them a name ? And the answer is yes , he does , but he never attempts to enumerate all of them .
Philo's Logos Theology and Divine Powers
Speaker 1Two powers in particular , the kingly and the beneficent , or occasionally , the kingly and the creative powers , are particularly important to Philo . Philo's dunamis or powers , are an attempt to preserve the transcendence and simplicity of God whilst accounting for the multiplicity of the world . Yes , but let's take a look again at the treatise on the special laws , where he says a little more about these powers . This time the treatise on the special laws , section 1 , paragraphs 49 , following Do not then hope ever to be able to apprehend me or any of my powers .
Speaker 1In our essence that's quite explicit and blunt , but continues Philo , I readily and with right goodwill will admit you to share of what is attainable . That means that I bid you come and contemplate the universe and its contents , a spectacle apprehended not by the eye of the body but by the unsleeping eyes of the noose . Only let there be a constant and profound longing for wisdom which fills its scholars and disciples with verities glorious in their exceeding loveliness . Here we have , as I said , a very clear statement to the effect that the apprehension of God or his powers is not possible . But he bids us , through Moses , to come and contemplate the universe and its contents , a spectacle apprehended not by the eye of the body but by the unsleeping eyes of the mind . So the vision of the universe and its contents . This sounds like what St Maximus the confessor identifies as natural contemplation that by the grace of the Holy Spirit , we are enabled to see the world as it truly is the world filled with the glory of God . Heaven and earth are full of Thy glory . This vision is bestowed upon man . Man's noose is enabled to behold creation , the universe as it is , as it really is , and so on and so forth .
Speaker 1Now , at this point , we have to introduce the second great contribution that Philo makes to philosophy , because even though very few pages are usually devoted to Philo in histories of philosophy , it cannot be ignored . And so he's there . And he's there because of the peculiar way that he presents the logos . As I said before , not by us , not by the church , but by philosophers , he's usually classed as a middle Platonist , and the middle Platonists , in their hierarchy of being , had a very special place for logos , the logos Now Philo's logos theology .
Speaker 1As Father Andrew Louth points out in his origins of the Christian mystical tradition , philo's logos theology is presented in the context of his understanding of the mystical way , and it is said that he's developing here the stoic idea of the divine logos or reason that underlies and fashions all things . For Philo , with his pronounced doctrine of a transcendent God , in contrast to the stoic imminentism , as soon as you start breaking down what Philo actually says , you see that he's not quite middle platinist . He doesn't fit into the middle platinist mold . And then he's not quite stoic , because the stoics had this imminentism , where the logos is everything , and you see that Philo's doctrine speaks of a transcendent God , where the logos is indeed a mediator between the transcendent God and the world , and so he has both transcendent and imminent aspects . But to cut a long story short , it doesn't fit comfortably in these categories , because these categories are not correct . It's not right to apply them to Philo .
Speaker 1Philo is coming from a totally different tradition . He's coming from the tradition of the Old Testament and , as we said before the minute , he introduces the created , uncreated distinction , the way that it exists in the Bible . He's in a totally different world , a fundamentally different world . And the proof of this , or one of the proofs of this , is that there's another very significant dimension to Philo's logos theology , which is seldom remarked upon . Father Andrew Louth brings it out in his book , but it concerns the idea of the logos , not as divine reason , as in philosophy , as in stoic philosophy , as in the other philosophies , but the idea of God as one who speaks , because the word for the one who speaks is olego . So the logos for Philo is the one who speaks . He's the one who said let us make man in our own image , after our own likeness . It's not difficult to see the connection , of course , based on Genesis 1 , between creating and speaking .
Speaker 1Now , in another treatise , on flight and finding , section 95 , philo speaks of the powers of him who speaks to Legondos in the genitive , the powers of the one who speaks , their leader , he says , being the creative power in the exercise of which the creator produced the universe by his word logo in the dative , the dative of instrument . We know from the Psalms that he spake and it was done . He commanded and it stood fast and they were created , and so on . So in another passage , this time in Philo's treatise on the cherubim , section 28 .
Speaker 1Philo is contemplating the mercy seat and he says in the midst between the two cherubs , the cherubim on the mercy seat , he says there is a third which unites them , logos . For it is through logos , the logos , that God is both ruler and good , of these two powers , sovereignty and goodness . The two cherubim are symbols , as the fiery sword is the symbol of the translation says reason . It's referring to the logos . Again , the fiery sword is the symbol of reason , For exceeding swift , and of burning heat is the logos , and chiefly so the logos of the cause capital C , for it alone preceded and outran all things conceived before them , all manifest above them all .
The Logos and the Two Powers
Speaker 1Why does the logos appear above and between the cherubim , who represent the two powers of God , two senior powers ? We can say this can be seen from the treatise on flight and finding , where we read that the logos is himself the image of God , chiefest of all beings intellectually perceived , placed nearest , with no intervening distance , to the alone truly existent one . For we read I will talk with thee from above the mercy seat between the two cherubim , exodus 25 , verse 21 . Words which show that while the logos is the charioteer of the powers , so he has the image of the chariot with two horses , the two powers . The charioteer is the logos , he who talks is seated in the chariot , giving direction to the charioteer for the right wielding of the reins of the universe . That's on flight and finding , section 101 .
Speaker 1So there's a very interesting image picture emerging from this , as Father Andrew Louth puts it . Although there seems to be some confusion as to whether the logos is the word spoken by God or the one to whom God speaks , it seems clear enough that in the word . There is direct communication with God as opposed to the indirect experience of him afforded by the other powers . I'm not sure about that , to tell you the truth , but I think it's true that the communication is between the one seated in the chariot and speaking and the charioteer , the one who's driving the chariot . And , interestingly , take a look at this Philo draws a distinction between the swift and the less sure footed In the soul's quest for God .
Speaker 1The swift will strive towards the divine logos , and he says again , on flight and finding the man who is capable of running swiftly , it bids not to stay to draw breath but to pass forward to the supreme divine logos , who is the fountain of wisdom , in order that he may draw from the stream and , released from death , gain life eternal as his prize .
Speaker 1When less sure footed , it directs to the power to which Moses gives the name God , since by it the universe was established and ordered . It urges him to flee for refuge to the creative power , knowing that to one who has grasped the fact that the whole world was brought into being , a vast good accrues , even the knowledge of its maker , which straightway wins the thing created to love him , to whom it owes its being One who is less ready , it urges to be , take himself to the kingly . Power , for fear of the sovereign , has a force of correction . To admonish the subject , where a father's kindness has none such for the child . Let's take a break and come back to unpack this passage , which is so important in the file of Alexandria's Logos Theology .