Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
“Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church”, with Prof. Christopher Veniamin
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present. Available Units thus far:
Unit 1: Introduction: Holy Scripture, Greek Philosophy, Philo of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 2: Irenaeus of Lyons (Season 3)
Unit 3: Clement the Alexandrian (Season 3)
Unit 4: Origen (Season 3)
Unit 5: Athanasius the Great (Season 3)
Unit 6: The Cappadocian Fathers (Season 3)
Unit 7: Augustine of Hippo (Season 3)
Unit 8: John Chrysostom (Season 3)
Unit 9: Cyril of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 14: Gregory Palamas (Season 1)
Unit 15: John of the Ladder (Season 4)
Unit 16: Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites (Season 2)
MISCELLANEOUS
Members-only: Special Editions (Season 5)
Empirical Dogmatics: The Theology of Fr. John Romanides (Season 6)
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies ; and The Enlargement of the Heart, by Archimandrite Zacharias ; Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022) ; The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016) ; The Transfiguration of Christ in Greek Patristic Literature (2022) ; and Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos, Empirical Dogmatics of the Orthodox Catholic Church: According to the Spoken Teaching of Father John Romanides, Vol. 1 (2012), Vol. 2 (repr. ed. 2020).
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the profound interrelationship between Orthodox theology and the Orthodox Christian life, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos contained therein.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: I wish to express my indebtedness to the spoken and written traditions of Sts Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites, Fr. Zacharias Zacharou, Fr. Kyrill Akon, Fr. Raphael Noica, Fr. Symeon Brüschweiler; Fr. John Romanides, Fr. Pavlos Englezakis, Fr. Georges Florovsky, Prof. Constantine Scouteris, Prof. George Mantzarides, Prof. John Fountoulis, Mtp Hierotheos Vlachos, Mtp Kallistos Ware, and Prof. Panayiotes Chrestou. My presentations have been enriched by all of the above sources. Responsibility however for the content of my presentations is of course mine alone. ©Christopher Veniamin 2024
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
Episode 7: “Clement of Alexandria”, Part 2; “Origen”, Part 1, in "Mystical Theology", with Dr. C. Veniamin
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Series: Mystical Theology
Episode 7: Clement of Alexandria, Part 2; Origen, Part 1
Introducing the theology and spiritual life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present.
This Episode, "Clement of Alexandria, Part 2; Origen, Part 1, continues Clement of Alexandria, Part 1, by counterbalancing Clement’s apophatic approach with his Christian biblical presuppositions; and then concludes with a note on the somewhat intellectualistic character of his theology. Origen, Part 1 begins with an introduction to this great Alexandrian’s “Sitz im Leben”, and then presents Origen’s ingenious doctrine of the spiritual senses.
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the interwoven character of theology and Christian living, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos.
Q&As related to Episode 7 available in The Professor’s Blog.
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: I wish to express my indebtedness to the spoken and written traditions of Sts Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites, Fr. Zacharias Zacharou, Fr. Kyrill Akon, Fr. Raphael Noica, Fr. Symeon Brüschweiler; Fr. John Romanides, Fr. Pavlos Englezakis, Fr. Georges Florovsky, Prof. Constantine Scouteris, Prof. George Mantzarides, Prof. John Fountoulis, and particularly to Mtp Kallistos Ware and Prof. Panayiotes Chrestou: certain sentences and phrases utilized in these presentations are taken directly from my notes of some of their lectures. My presentations have been enriched by all of the above sources, owing to the adoption of certain structures, lists, schemata, and the paraphrasing of themes taken from them. Responsibility for the content of my presentations is of course mine alone. ©Christopher Veniamin 2023
Join the Mount Thabor Academy Podcasts and help us to bring podcasts on Orthodox theology and the spiritual life to the wider community.
If you enjoy our podcast, consider supporting our The Mount Thabor Academy Patreon page, to unlock exclusive, member-only content.
Print Books by MOUNT THABOR PUBLISHING
eBooks Amazon Kindle
Contact us: info@mountthabor.com
Dr. Christopher Veniamin D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Counterbalancing Clement's Apophatic Theology with his Biblical Presuppositions
Speaker 1Okay . So let's take a look at five points to counterbalance Clament of Alexandria's apophatic usage Again , I'm deeply indebted here to Metropolitan Kalistos , where . So the first point is God's immanence , immunnence with an A . The second is theosis , divinization or deification . The third is Clament's emphasis on grace . Fourth is emphasis on the incarnation of Christ and finally his many references to love . So first then , divine immanence .
Speaker 1We had said that in his Stramatis , book five , paragraph 11 , clament writes God is far off in his essence but very near in his power to all things , quoting Proverbs three , seven and three , 12 . I am a God who is near . Clament qualifies this by saying far away in his essence For how is it possible for the created to be related to the uncreated but very near in his power , by which all things are embraced . So alongside the transcendent essence , we have the imminent power of God , in which we do participate , and later theologians refer to God's power here as his energies . Energy or energies . Secondly , theosis , deification is the effect of this participation . What does this participation in the power of God bring about ? It brings about our salvation , which is understood in terms of theosis , becoming like God , becoming like Christ . Salvation involves a process of divinization , theobesis , a bold statement , but in Psalm 82 , verse six , we read I said you are God's . And this , of course , is quoted by Christ himself in the Gospel , according to St John , chapter 10 , verse 34 .
Speaker 1The early apologist Theophilus twice talks about humans becoming gods , becoming gods , in his work to Autolicus , book two , paragraphs 24 and 27 . Irenaeus , in his preface to book five of his against the heresies , says that he became what we are so that we might become what he is , and he speaks of Medohi Theu , partakers of God . The word Theobior , in reference to the human person , is found in Hippolytus in his Philosophumena , book 10 , 34 , otherwise known as the refutation of all the heresies , refutatio omnium heresium . Clement of Alexandria uses such language rather more frequently than Hippolytus and furthermore , like Irenaeus , clement emphasizes that this process is unending , begins in this life , and it continues in the next Stramatis , book two , paragraph two . This reminds us of Irenaeus and points forward to Gregory of Nisa , but not only .
Speaker 1What about his emphasis on grace , then ? Well , the first thing that we need to state quite clearly is that , for Clement , the soul is not divine by nature . So when he uses Platonist language , when he seems to use Platonist concepts , his context is fundamentally different . Everything is a gift of God , freely given . The soul is not divine by nature , and so knowledge of God is always a gift of grace . If we turn to the next point , with grace in mind , in other words to his emphasis on the incarnation , clement says that all knowledge of God is achieved in and through Christ . It remains that we Christians apprehend the unknown , he says , by divine grace and by the Logos who alone is from him . This , as we said before , he goes on to talk about St Paul's address on Mars Hill , arios Parcos , on the altar of the unknown God , which sums up Clement's apophatic theology .
Speaker 1Person of Jesus Christ is beyond every philosophical category . And what about the many references to love ? I've already mentioned to you how the word love , when applied to God for the philosophical milieu , is a bit of a joke . But Clement emphasizes divine love . In his Traumatis , book five , paragraph one , he quotes that God is love . And so the apophatic way , the via negativa , is actually the via amoris , the way of love . And in his famous treatise , who is the Rich man that Will Be Saved , quistives Salvatore , chapter 27 , he explains to us that the more one loves God , the more he enters into him . So there are at least five ways by which the strong apophatic approach of Clement is counterbalanced .
Speaker 1We see that there is also an absence in Clement . Clement nowhere talks about mystical ecstasy , which is also true of origin and later of Evagrius of Pontus . When used usually means madness or even astonishment , but the notion of mystical ecstasy is to be found in Dionysius , the Areopagai , for example , of fundamental importance , and Gregory of Nisa in particular . But again , not only . Why do we not find it in Clement and origin ? Well , metropolitan Callistos says , perhaps they are reacting against mountainism , its notion of prophecy , in which the person prophesying does not understand what he's saying . And both Clement and origin make the point that the Holy Spirit does not cause one to lose consciousness , only demons do that . God , on the contrary , makes our normal understanding clearer . So a word by way of conclusion .
Speaker 1We have in Clement an emphasis on the unknowability of God , but at the same time of participation in him . The fact that God cannot be known does not prevent us from participating in him , experiencing God . And secondly , and in connection with this directly , is the fact that this participation is brought about by grace , through the incarnation of Jesus Christ and love . So we can say that , yes , there are intellectual tendencies in Clement , but his approach is affirmative and orthodox . When we say that God is unknowable , according to Clement , he's pointing us away from thought and concept but not from experience . And I think that's the fundamental distinction the fact that we cannot understand God or contain God in terms of our thoughts and our concepts . We find that they're ultimately inadequate .
Speaker 1Nevertheless , that does not mean that we do not know God in the experiential sense . And I think that's what Clement , as is the case with the patristic tradition in general , is trying to tell us . Firstly , of course , he's speaking to his immediate audience and we should remember that , that he's speaking to people who are versed well versed , in the philosophy of Plato and the others and I would say , more serious forms of philosophy , because the philosophers in those days , they tried to live what they believed . But Clement is saying that , on the one hand , we found the true philosophy and , on the other , that true philosophy transcends what we think of when we think of God , what we conceive of , when we try to conceive of God . The experience of the Christian God transcends that of the philosophers .
Speaker 1That's what he's driving at and that's the difficult question when you arrive at theological dialogue or discourse on the basis of experience , then you have to be extremely careful about your criteria and your presuppositions Because you can't just say , well , I have this experience , you have that experience . It's all experience . What is genuine experience of God and what is not ? And I think that In Clement we see the criteria , we see the fundamental distinctions that help us to know the limitations of our created human nature and the gift of God , that everything is by grace , that everything is given in and through the assumed human flesh of Christ . His emphasis on love is very important because love contains all the virtues , humility , forgiveness , all these things which help us to understand that this is a genuine experience of God . You shall know them by their fruits . What engenders love ? Humility , repentance , forgiveness . Then you know you're safe , then you know you're treading on sure ground . The culmination of Christian love , divine love , is that love which embraces everyone and everything , including one's enemies . That's the criteria . We'll talk more about these things , god willing , when we move on a little bit .
Speaker 1But regarding St Photius the Great's critique of Clement of Alexandria and Clement's reception in the Orthodox tradition , I can only tell you what I think , based on my limited exposure of Clement and his writings and patristic tradition in general and I would say that there is an intellectual dimension to Clement which is probably a little too emphasised . I'm not saying he's not Orthodox , but I would say it's perceived as being more on the intellectual level . It might not be entirely fair , but that's what I suspect . The early Alexandre Clement and Origin are perhaps a little too influenced intellectually by the world around them . Again , that may be normal to a certain degree . We all are to a certain degree . But I think you'll see more clearly the strengths and the weaknesses of Clement when we turn to Origin , because the curious thing about Origin is that it's both more biblical than Clement . Clement gives a little too much to pagan Béthia , pagan wisdom perhaps , and Origin is both too generous in that direction , but he's also more biblical and he's more philosophical . But you'll see what I mean by that .
Speaker 1This is a difficult chapter in early Christian doctrine , but I think what you are witnessing to a significant degree is how Christianity is engaging with the world around it but at the same time trying to express clearly it is not the world around it , it's something other than what the world has to offer . The best of what the world has to offer points to Christianity , but Christianity transcends the wisdom of this world . This is a very important theme , which one of my professors at Thessalonica , father John Romanides , used to say . It's not easy to understand that the church creates culture , but herself transcends culture . The church has created tremendous cultures , perhaps the greatest cultures ever , but she herself transcends culture . The culture of the church is not of this world .
Speaker 1So Origin , whose years are from around 185 to 254 or 255 , his place in the history of Christian thought is itself a paradox . He's deeply influential and at the same time deeply controversial . We have such great saints as Gregory the Wonderworker , who regarded Origin as second only to the apostles , in his authority , in his manner of life , and so on and so forth , pamphylus the martyr , and others . Here we have the great Cappadocian fathers , basil and Gregory the Theologian , with great reverence , selecting excerpts from his writings to produce the first Philokalia . It's obvious that others , such as John Chrysostom , maximus the Confessor I'm just choosing but a few names had read Origin and read him very , very carefully .
Speaker 1I said a moment ago that it's correct to perceive Origin as a philosopher , as an intellectualist , but at the same time as a man of prayer , as a man of devotion , because he seems to be both of these at once . It could be argued that in comparison with Clement , he's both more Platonist and more biblical . We know , usually what we learn about Origin in if you'll forgive me rather superficial histories of the church is that he believed in the pre-existence of the soul , the cosmic fall , and that his understanding of the apocatastasis , the restoration of all things , was heretical . But Origin is a great lover of holy scripture , a great lover of the church . We find in Origin's writings a very warm devotion to Jesus Christ , for Jesus Christ , his labor of love , his famous hexapla , meaning six columns , was made up of . The first column was the Hebrew text , the second column a transliteration of the Hebrew text in Greek letters . The third column was the Septuagint translation , the fourth the translation of Simacus , the fifth the translation of Theodotian and the sixth the fanatically literal translation of Achilla . And , by the way , when it came to the book of Psalms , he added another two columns , making it an octapla . So two more translations were added , one of which Origin found , interestingly , in a jar by the Jordan . It seemed to have been an archaeologist as well .
Origen's Doctrine of the Spiritual Senses
Speaker 1But not only that , origin is also a great ascetic with a passionate desire for martyrdom . If you take a look at Eusebius's Ecclesiastical History , book 6 , section 3 , paragraphs 9 to 12 , you'll see that , unlike Justin and Clement , origin was a child of Christian parents . His father , leonides , died as a martyr , and Origin observed this and was only stopped from offering himself for martyrdom by his mother , who took his clothes away . But he was a martyr inwardly , and he writes about this . He describes two different forms of martyrdom . He says there's the outer , which we cannot choose , but there's an inward martyrdom , which is open to everyone . There is , of course , a tradition found in Eusebius which claims he took literally Christ's words on eunuchs , but it's not certain . We're not sure that this is what he actually did . It would be curious that someone who's described as being such a lover of allegory would take these particular words so literally . But in any case , origin is a paradox . Origin is difficult to categorize . He was ordained later in life to the priesthood in Palestine . He had fallen out of favor with his bishop in Alexandria and moved to Palestine , and there he was eventually ordained .
Speaker 1If you want to take a look at , let's say , origin the pious Christian as opposed to Origin the Platonist , take a look at his works on martyrdom , at his writings on prayer and his interpretation of the song of songs . Just briefly , let's take a look at his treatment of the song of songs , where , for Origin , the bride in the song of songs is understood as the soul . This is important because usually the bride is described as the church , and Hippolytus of Rome , who was the first to write a commentary on the song of songs , gives this more ecclesiastical interpretation . But Origin speaks of the mystical kiss of the bridegroom , and the bride is the soul . So let's look more closely at Origin's interpretation of the song of songs and note one or two of its most important features .
Speaker 1First of all , in Origin there is the theme of interiority , as the stress , in other words , on the indwelling presence of the logos , and Origin says that the logos dwells in the hegemonicon of the soul , the leading or guiding principle of the soul . In the Latin translation it's translated as the principale cordis or the seat of the heart . The point is that self discovery for Origin , more one goes deeper into oneself , there one discovers God . Self discovery is God discovery , based on the ancient principle , perhaps , of know thyself . But Clement , we had said , has the theme of to know God is to become like God . Well , origin gives this a distinctly Christian emphasis . Knowledge of oneself is knowledge of Christ and ultimately it's more correct to say with Origin and we'll explain why a little later that knowledge of oneself is knowledge of the logos . Normally I wouldn't make the distinction between the logos and Christ , but I think that in Origin there are reasons for doing so . Okay , one more point about Origin's interpretation of the song of songs .
Speaker 1Here he introduces something that has fascinated theologians for centuries he develops a doctrine of the spiritual senses . Beside bodily senses , origin says there exist the spiritual senses . We have a sensuality , origin writes , that has nothing sensual in it . Quote unquote , contrakelso , book one , paragraph 48 , and book seven , paragraph 34 . What is the scriptural basis for this doctrine of the spiritual senses ? Well , he takes from Proverbs 2.5 , which says that you will discover , you will find a divine sense , sense in the meaning of senses . You will discover , you will find od di thean estisin evrisis . You will find a divine sense . Now let's break this down a little bit . The doctrine of spiritual senses of which Origin is the pioneer . You have such persons as the famous Karl Rahner , who wrote the spiritual senses according to origin . Anybody who knows the writings at all of Karl Rahner , you know that he's a speculative theologian , dogmatic , systematic theologian , so that he wrote on the spiritual senses according to origin in itself is something that makes you sit back and notice . This article , which is in English , by the way , published in something called Theological Investigations , volume 16 , london 1979 , is an abridged version of a French article more detailed , but nevertheless , even such modern systematic theologians such as Rahner have taken notice of , and they like , the richness , the suggestiveness of origin's doctrine of the spiritual senses .
Speaker 1So we have vision , hearing , tasting , smelling and touching . Vision or assis origin , says , or he points to such passages as John 1 32 , where St John the Baptist saw the Holy Spirit descend . Now , it's interesting because 32 to 34 says I saw the Spirit descend as a dove from heaven and it remained on him . And then he on whom you see the Spirit descend and remain , this is he who baptizes with the Holy Spirit and I have seen and have borne witness that this is the Son of God . Vision understood by origin in a spiritual sense , not a physical one . John 1 , 51 , truly , truly , I say to you , you will see heaven opened and the angels of God ascending and descending upon the Son of man . Another reference to a spiritual vision , not a physical one . Matthew 17 9 . And as they were coming down the mountain , jesus commanded them tell no man the vision after the transfiguration , tell no man the vision until the Son of man is raised from the dead Again . This is a spiritual vision , first and foremost . Then we have hearing agoi .
Speaker 1Origin refers to 2 Corinthians , 12 , 2 to 4 , where St Paul says that he knows a man in Christ who 14 years ago , was caught up into the third heaven , and so on and so forth , and he heard things that cannot be told . He heard unspeakable words . Spiritual hearing , according to origin . John , chapter 5, . Do not marvel at this , for the hour is coming when all who are in the tombs will hear his voice , verse 28, . Spiritual hearing , tasting . Well , there are references in John , chapter 6 , of course , to the bread of life , the bread of God that comes down from heaven hunger , thirst , all of which imply tasting . But if that's not good enough for you , origin points to Ezekiel , chapter 2 , where he is told Son of man , eat what is offered to you , eat this scroll and go speak to the house of Israel . And at the end of the passage , or 3 , 3 , chapter 3 , verse 3 says then I ate it and it was in my mouth as sweet as honey , tasting there .
Speaker 1Origin says that's spiritual tasting , sense of spiritual taste , smelling , 2 Corinthians 2 , 15 , for we are the aroma of Christ to God among those who are being saved and among those who are perishing . And in Genesis 27 , 27 , jacob comes near to Isaac , kisses him and he smelled the smell of his garments and blessed him and said See , the smell of my son is as the smell of a field which the Lord has blessed , spiritual sense of smell and touching . Where might that be ? Well , for origin it's 1 John 1 , 1 . That which was from the beginning , which we have heard , which we have seen with our eyes , which we have looked upon and touched with our hands , concerning the word of life , but also Matthew 8 , 3 , and he stretched out his hand and touched him , saying I will be clean , and immediately his leprosy was cleansed . Well , there , it's interesting that origin says I know that Christ touched him , but first and foremost this was a spiritual touch .
Speaker 1The physical is secondary . So we have here the idea of direct contact with great richness and variety . God is not merely a theme for cerebral speculation , but of unmediated experience of God , involving every aspect of man's being . Now , it's important to note that these spiritual senses need to be developed , according to origin , through spiritual labours .
Speaker 1Ascesis exercise spiritual labour and in his commentary on the canticum canticorum , the song of songs , one for origin contrasts a man who is engaged in ascesis , one who is engaged in spiritual training , spiritual labours . He contrasts such a man to the animalis homo , the psichicos antropos of 1 Corinthians , 2 , 14 . And the chief object of this ascesis , according to origin , is always the person of Christ . Origin , as we've said , is deeply Christocentric . Take a look at the commentary on the song of songs , 1 , 4 and also his first homily . He has a commentary on the song of songs and he has two homilies , also on the song of songs , his first homily , paragraph 5 . And , by the way , I think the Lawson translation is excellent .
Speaker 1Now something that's not so easy to understand . For origin , it's important to set out the context of the spiritual and its relationship to the physical . We've already noted that the spiritual has the preeminence . In origin's way of thinking , that which is spiritual is superior to that which is physical . But it's important to note , as I say , that the historical Christ , for origin , is a sacrament of the spiritual Christ . I'll say that again . The historical Christ is a sacrament of the spiritual Christ . The visible is a sacrament of the invisible . The humanity of Christ is a means of approach to the logos , who is the real food of the soul . That's a quotation . That last part there , and I'll say that again , is a quotation from Cardinal Jean Danielou . The humanity of Christ is quote a means of approach to the logos , who is the real food of the soul . Unquote .
The Significance of Origen's Concept of God
Speaker 1Danielou wrote what's probably still the best monograph on origin . He wrote a brilliant book on Gregory of Nisa , but he also wrote on origin . That's very fine work . It's in English and the page is 263 where I took that quotation from . It's just called Origin , written by Jean Danielou .
Speaker 1So we need to unpack this a little bit , explain it . In what sense is the historical Christ a sacrament of the spiritual Christ ? The visible is a sacrament of the invisible . The humanity of Christ is a means of approach to the logos . What Origin calls the naked logos , the pure logos , the spiritual logos ? Who is the real food of the soul ? So you see , in Origin he doesn't have a disparaging view of the physical . He sees it as something that's necessary in the saving work of Christ . But everything is designed to raise us up and away from the physical to the spiritual , and Danielou is paraphrasing Origin quite faithfully here when he says it's the spiritual logos who is the real food of the soul . There's so much that can be said here . Yes , we'll come back to this point and elaborate upon it when we talk about how Origin understands God as intellectualis natura simplex , as a simple intellectual nature .