Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
“Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church”, with Prof. Christopher Veniamin
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present. Available Units thus far:
Unit 1: Introduction: Holy Scripture, Greek Philosophy, Philo of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 2: Irenaeus of Lyons (Season 3)
Unit 3: Clement the Alexandrian (Season 3)
Unit 4: Origen (Season 3)
Unit 5: Athanasius the Great (Season 3)
Unit 6: The Cappadocian Fathers (Season 3)
Unit 7: Augustine of Hippo (Season 3)
Unit 8: John Chrysostom (Season 3)
Unit 9: Cyril of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 14: Gregory Palamas (Season 1)
Unit 15: John of the Ladder (Season 4)
Unit 16: Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites (Season 2)
MISCELLANEOUS
Members-only: Special Editions (Season 5)
Empirical Dogmatics: The Theology of Fr. John Romanides (Season 6)
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies ; and The Enlargement of the Heart, by Archimandrite Zacharias ; Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022) ; The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016) ; The Transfiguration of Christ in Greek Patristic Literature (2022) ; and Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos, Empirical Dogmatics of the Orthodox Catholic Church: According to the Spoken Teaching of Father John Romanides, Vol. 1 (2012), Vol. 2 (repr. ed. 2020).
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the profound interrelationship between Orthodox theology and the Orthodox Christian life, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos contained therein.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: I wish to express my indebtedness to the spoken and written traditions of Sts Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites, Fr. Zacharias Zacharou, Fr. Kyrill Akon, Fr. Raphael Noica, Fr. Symeon Brüschweiler; Fr. John Romanides, Fr. Pavlos Englezakis, Fr. Georges Florovsky, Prof. Constantine Scouteris, Prof. George Mantzarides, Prof. John Fountoulis, Mtp Hierotheos Vlachos, Mtp Kallistos Ware, and Prof. Panayiotes Chrestou. My presentations have been enriched by all of the above sources. Responsibility however for the content of my presentations is of course mine alone. ©Christopher Veniamin 2024
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
Episode 10: "What Every Orthodox Christian Should Know About the Orthodox Faith", in "Mystical Theology", with Prof. C. Veniamin
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Series: Mystical Theology
Episode 10: What Every Orthodox Christian Should Know About the Orthodox Faith
Introducing the theology and spiritual life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present.
In Episode 10, “What Every Orthodox Christian Should Know About the Orthodox Faith" is based on a presentation made by Mtp Hierotheos Vlachos on the theology of Fr. John Romanides, one of the leading Greek Orthodox theologians of the 20th century. Revised and presented by Prof. Christopher Veniamin, this podcast covers a number of significant themes for the Life in Christ, including those listed in the Timestamps below.
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the interwoven character of theology and Christian living, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos.
Q&As related to Episode 10 available in The Professor’s Blog.
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022): ; The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016); and Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos, Empirical Dogmatics of the Orthodox Catholic Church: According to the Spoken Teaching of Father John Romanides, Vol. 1 (2012), Vol. 2 (repr. ed. 2020).
Join the Mount Thabor Academy Podcasts and help us to bring podcasts on Orthodox theology and the spiritual life to the wider community.
If you enjoy our podcast, consider supporting our The Mount Thabor Academy Patreon page, to unlock exclusive, member-only content.
Print Books by MOUNT THABOR PUBLISHING
eBooks Amazon Kindle
Contact us: info@mountthabor.com
Dr. Christopher Veniamin D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Intro
Speaker 1What is orthodox theology and what makes it distinct or unique from any other theology . We had already said by way of introduction that whatever we study , whatever we look at , really what we are trying to discern are these
Preamble
Speaker 1theological presuppositions that distinguish orthodox theology from any other theology . So we're trying to learn these presuppositions , which themselves , however , are not just a matter of thinking straight . They're not just a matter of getting the
Ten Essential Points
Speaker 1ratio , the rational aspect of yourselves to think correctly , because within these presuppositions are contained something very important , an ethos that's a spirit . Within the doctrines of the church , within the teachings of the holy scriptures and the fathers , there is an ethos to be not only learned in an intellectual way but to be absorbed . I had mentioned to you also that a friend of mine , metropolitan Iros Vlajos , who has written many books on the orthodox way and ethos and distinctiveness , was looking for the theology that he found when he was asked to read through the writings of Saint Gregory Palamas and highlight and identify Palamas' references to Gregory the Theologian . That was a turning point in his life because what he read was really quite remarkable to him and it made him think that this theology were written in the fourth century and again in the 14th century . Somewhere , this theology must still exist Somewhere , this theology that's based on a life of prayer , that's based on the understanding that the only truly genuine sign of a healthy soul as we've said before is the vision of God . When he was able to meet people who actually knew theology meaning they knew Christ he began to see that orthodox theology is not actually a religion . Because what is a religion ? What is a thriskya ? A thriskya , a religion is something that's designed to satisfy our emotional and psychological needs . A religion is what Father John Romanides used to call a neurobiological illness . It has nothing to do , nothing whatsoever to do with the Christian faith . The teachings of our church , without life , are like black coals that have remained unlit . The purpose of the Christian life is that we might become like the creator and author of our salvation , jesus Christ . As we said before , it's not about do's and don'ts , and those do's and don'ts are sometimes understood in different ways , but still they're do's and don'ts . They're a system of morals , rules and outward forms of discipline , which may be helpful in some ways , but do not constitute the essence of the Christian life . What are the central points ? What are the basic presuppositions of the Orthodox faith , the Orthodox patristic faith , the faith of the fathers , which heals , which transforms our fallen nature and regenerates it and renews it and makes it like unto Christ .
Speaker 1Let's turn for a moment , then , before we go further in our patristic journey , to some of the basic presuppositions , some of the basic assumptions , pointers that contain this ethos that we're talking about . Firstly , the God of the church is the God of Revelation . That means that God has revealed Himself to the saints . This revelation is called Theoria , or Theoptiia , contemplation , vision of God . The saints see God in light , just as the three disciples on Mount Tabor saw Christ in the light . Not only do they see the light , but they live in the light . We've already encountered this in none other than Aaron Hesovlion , a spiritual grandchild of the apostles . At that
1. The God of Revelation
Speaker 1point , the one who is deified Otheumenos has no thoughts but exists above thoughts and above the senses . This is important because in the West , as you know , it's come to be understood that the highest level of our being is reason . So take note , nota Bene At this point , the one who is deified has no thoughts but exists above thoughts and above the senses .
Speaker 1Then he hears uncreated words and uncreated thoughts , unspeakable words , as St Paul says in 2 Corinthians , chapter 12 . Uncreated means something which has no beginning and no end . The prophet , or saint , describes this experience by means of created words , created words , concepts , images , created words , created concepts , created images . And in this way are the doctrines made in order , on the one hand , to guide the faithful and , on the other hand , to safeguard against false doctrines . Now , when God this is the second point when God reveals himself as light , that light is a threefold light . God is three lights .
Speaker 1Once upon a time , the Apostle Philip asked Christ , show us the Father and it sufficeth us . John 14 , verse 8 . And Christ said have I been so long time with you and yet hast thou not known me , philip ? He that hath seen me hath seen the Father . John 14 , 9 . Which is to say , the saints behold the threefold light of the divinity .
2. Threefold Light of the Divinity
Speaker 1This does not mean that they behold the light outside of themselves , but they participate in God , that is to say , they participate in the glory of God , in the uncreated energy of God . They understand , however , and they experience the fact that they cannot see the source from which the light comes . Therefore , they call that which they see energy and that which they cannot see essence , and they said that we participate in the energy of God , but we do not participate in the essence of God . When we say that God has essence and energy , the Fathers do not understand this in a philosophical way . This is not philosophy that they are doing , even though we know that these terms exist in philosophy , in their important terms . They understand these terms in an experiential way , by experience . This is an empirical event , in other words , not speculation . It's the result of experience , not of philosophical speculation .
Speaker 1Now , thirdly , the Holy Trinity appears in the Old Testament and not only in the new . All of the manifestations of God in the Old Testament are manifestations of the pre-incarnate Logos , who is also called the Angel of Great Council by the prophet Isaiah . Isaiah 9.6 , septuagint . We have , therefore , the pre-incarnate Logos , who is referred to as Yahweh here it is that is revealed . And there is God , who is called Elohim , who
3. Trinity in OT / Diff. btw OT & NT
Speaker 1is hidden , concealed , and we also have Ruach Elohim , the Spirit of God , or Ruach Adonai , the Spirit of the Lord , the Spirit of Yahweh . This is the threefold light of the divinity Elohim , yahweh , ruach Elohim , ruach Adonai . In the New Testament , yahweh is made flesh , becomes man and reveals to us his Father and the Holy Spirit .
Speaker 1The difference between the Old Testament and the New Testament is that in the Old Testament we have the pre-incarnate logos , manifestations of the pre-incarnate logos , and in the New Testament we have manifestations of the incarnate logos . In the New Testament we now know clearly the Father , the Son and the Holy Spirit . Through Christ , we know the Father without seeing him , john 14.9 . Father John Romanides used to say the saints see the light , the threefold divine light , through the light , that is , through Christ . They see the light . They say they see the light of the Father without seeing the Father and they see it while they are in the light of the Holy Spirit . The phrase is through the light , the light in the light , and this can be found in the empirical dogmatics of Metropolitan Eros Theos .
Speaker 1Next is the teaching that the triune God created the world through the logos and man , his most perfect creature , his most perfect creation . God is uncreated . The world and man are created . Adam and Eve had a soul and body , but also the grace of God . We've already alluded to this . They had personal communion with God . They spoke with God , which means they had communion and a relationship with God . They lived in the light of God , and that is natural man , that is to say , a natural man
4. World created by Triune God / God uncreated - World & Man created
Speaker 1is one who has a body , a soul and also the Holy Spirit . Man is not comprised of three parts . He's comprised of two parts body and soul . But the Holy Spirit exists in both his soul and his body . This is indeed the genuine man created by God , who lives in the light .
Speaker 1Father Romanides used to say and you know that he studied the question of the fall in great detail . This was the subject of his doctoral dissertation , which had a tremendous impact on the direction and character of Orthodox theology in Greece , which , up until that time , was still , as in other places , in a certain captivity to Neo-Tomism . Father Romanides used to say that the fathers , based on the experience that they had themselves , interpreted how Adam lived in paradise . And indeed St John Chrysostom says that Adam and Eve in paradise lived as angels .
Speaker 1Now this fifth point that the fall of man is not simply a legal matter , it's not simply a case of disobeying a commandment . So what is it ? Well , in simple terms , it's the loss of the very experience of the glory of God . The apostle Paul , in his epistle to the Romans , says all have sinned and have been deprived of the glory of God . Easterunde , they've been deprived of the glory of God , romans 3 , 23 .
Speaker 1The King James says fallen short , it's deprived , been deprived of the glory
5. Correct understanding of the Fall
Speaker 1of God . That is to say , the fall is the loss of the grace of God . This is spiritual death , and that is to say , after the sin , the soul and the body remained , but they lost the Holy Spirit . That is what is meant by the ancestral sin spiritual death which was followed by physical death , the death of the body . The inheritance of the ancestral sin is not an inheritance of guilt , as St Augustine used to say , but it is the corruption and death which entered into man , and it is this that is transmitted from generation to generation in the birth of newborn infants .
Speaker 1A natural man had two energies in his soul , the one his reason and the other his noose , that is to say rational energy and spiritual energy respectively . By means of the spiritual energy he would see the glory of God in paradise , and by means of the rational energy , man could describe , write down his experience . After the fall . Man's spiritual energy was darkened , but not his rational energy , and he lost his communion with God because the noose was darkened . The prophets in the Old Testament strove with the help of God and their minds were illumined , but they were unable to overcome death , which is why they went down into Hades . The problem , therefore , is how to illumine the noose of man , which means the noose needs to be separated from our rational energy Because , as Father Romanides used to say , the fall is the identification of our rational energy with our spiritual energy . They're confused . We don't know . We don't know the difference between rational energy and spiritual energy . We're not aware that we even have a noose .
Speaker 1The prophet Moses went up to Sinai and saw with his noose , so with his spiritual energy , the glory of God and afterwards , with his reasoning power , wrote down his experience . But he went down into Hades because he was unable to defeat death . The triumph over death came with the incarnation of God . Ok , so point number six Christ comes , assuming our mortal and corruptible body , in order to overcome death and also to overcome sin and the devil and consequently to restore man to his state before the fall and to raise him even higher . Christ taught by means of parables , performed miracles , but he took some of his disciples up to Mount Tabor and showed them his glory . He wanted to show them that they were to follow his teaching , put it into practice in order to behold wonders , but most especially
6. Significance of Incarnation
Speaker 1in order to see the glory of God . This is the deepest purpose of the spiritual life For us to overcome spiritual death , that is to say our separation from God , so that later we will overcome the death of the body .
Speaker 17 . The work of salvation takes place in the church . The church existed in the Old Testament in the communion that the prophets had with the pre-incarnate Logos , but it was a spiritual church . After the incarnation the church becomes enfleshed , that is to say also physical . We become members of the body of Christ . On the day of Pentecost the apostles received the Holy Spirit , and then the apostles learned all the truth . Christ told them that he would send the Holy Spirit and that he would teach them all the truth . John 16-13 .
7. Salvation in Church / Church before & after Incarnation
Speaker 1When the priest during the divine liturgy divides the host , meaning the consecrated bread , he says the Lamb of God is broken and yet not divided In the church .
Speaker 1By means of holy baptism and holy chrismation , man becomes a temple of the Holy Spirit . Know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you ? Says Saint Paul in 1 Corinthians 619 . What does he becomes a temple of the Holy Spirit mean ? It means that in his being is activated , his spiritual energy and spiritual prayer is born in him .
Speaker 1Unceasing prayer , prayer of the heart . Man's body is a temple , and just as the temple in its innermost sanctuary has its altar , so too in the depths of the heart , by means of holy baptism and holy chrismation , a holy altar is formed and within the heart takes place an unceasing divine liturgy , in which case man is restored to his former state in paradise , and even much higher . For now , the divine liturgy takes place within him , within his very body . There is reasonable prayer which takes place in the brain , and there is spiritual prayer which takes place in the heart . Reaching that state constitutes the therapy of the human person . One must reach the stage in which one has inner prayer and love for God , passion for God . That is why many fathers emphasize that there are three stages in the spiritual life the purification of the heart , the illumination of the mind , the noose , and deification , theosis . Just as we have in the church building the narthex . We have the purification of the heart , then we have the nave , which is the illumination of the noose , and we have the holy altar , which is theosis .
Speaker 1Further , john Romanides used to say , because he was an ascetic theologian , that the church has two aspects , the one positive and one negative . The positive aspect is Christology , that is to say , it tells us about Christ , while the negative aspect tells us about the devil and how to strive against the devil . The more one learns to fight against the devil , that is to say , the more one learns the negative aspect of the life of the church , the more one comes to know the positive aspect of the church , which is Christ . That is why man must continually strive against the devil , for in this way he learns the love of Christ . It is very important for us to know that the grace of God and the light of God come into man via his heart and through the heart a co-mingling takes place . The devil is outside man and wars against him from without . That is why we say that those who have been deified know the devil , that he is outside by virtue of association with him . We live in the church in order to be healed , which means that we must pass through the states of servants , hired , laborers and reach the status of children of God .
Speaker 1Romans 8 , 16 to 17 . Father John Romanides used to say that heresy is the rejection of the quote unquote methodology that allows us to arrive at the knowledge of God . That is to say , every discipline has its method , and if you do not follow the method , you will not reach your objective . Now , the method quote unquote to which Father John referred is purification , illumination , theosis . When this method is rejected , then we end up speculating about God , and when one speculates about God , logic and fantasy enter in and we end up in heresy . Father John used to say that people become heretics when there are no prophets who can teach the method of the knowledge of God . Note , however , that he was well aware of the fact that no method or technique quote unquote exists by which the mind , the noose , may be reunited with the heart . More about that later .
Speaker 18 . That the eschatological life is not the life after the Second Coming of Christ . The eschatological life is not the life after the Second Coming of Christ , but it is the life in Christ . Some say that we shall live the eschaton following the Second Coming of Christ . This is wrong . In the book of Revelation it says that Christ is the first and the last . With the incarnation of Christ , therefore , the eschaton enters history . In this way , the Kingdom of God enters the world
8. The Eschaton = Life in Christ
Speaker 1and history and men are able to participate in the Kingdom of God .
Speaker 1When the saints see God , theoptia , they live the eschaton , the Kingdom of God . They see it now , in this very life . This is called the first resurrection , and the second resurrection will be after the resurrection of the body , after the coming of Christ . The saints see the light through deification . This is what we sing in the great doxology , sung at the end of Mattens In thy light shall we see light . We live , that is , in the light of the Holy Spirit , in purification and illumination , and we see the light .
Speaker 1Then point number nine paradise and hell exist from the perspective of man and not from the perspective of God . God did not create paradise and hell . God is light and illumines the whole universe Created . Light has two characteristics it both illumines and burns . Some are illumined and some are burnt by it . God is the uncreated light . Some participate in the
9. Paradise & Hell
Speaker 1light and some are burnt by it because they are not ready to accept the light . If one does not have the eyes to see the light , then one is burnt by it .
Speaker 1When Christ would speak of hell , he would sometimes refer to it as darkness and sometimes as fire . But wherever there is fire , there is no darkness , and wherever there is darkness there can be no fire , which means that hell is neither darkness nor fire as we understand darkness and fire . God loves all men , even sinners , and he sends them his grace . Those that have been healed in this life and have acquired unselfish love will see the light . Those that have not been healed will not see the light , but they will experience the light , the light of God , as fire . That is why the fire of hell is uncreated , not created . This is very beautifully depicted in iconography . From the throne of God the light emanates and illumines the saints , and from the throne of God comes the river of fire which engulfs sinners , which means that the river of fire is uncreated . That is why , in the church , we strive so that when we see God because all of us shall see God , both sinners and righteous God will be for us light and not hell .
Speaker 1This takes place in Holy Communion . Those who prepare as His meat feel the light and those who do not prepare and receive unworthily are condemned . The saints in the kingdom of God will not exist in a static state , as Plato used to say about happiness and also Saint Augustine , but they will be in a constant state of progression or growth . Rather , there will be a continuous movement , while sinners , those that have not repented , will experience a certain hardening and they will not experience this growth .
Speaker 1And number 10 , father Romanides used to say that Christ , by his incarnation , became man and entered history . The church lives within history and sanctifies history . History will not end as such , but it will be transfigured . There are some that say after the second coming , history will come to an end . Father Romanides used to say that this is a mistake , because after the second coming , history will exist in paradise , but it will assume a different character . It will be transformed .
10. Transfiguration of History
Speaker 1The saints had this experience and they used their environment in order to express it , either in words or in iconography or in poetry . They took elements from Hebrew thought , greek thought and from Roman culture , but only in an effort to express revelation and not in order to create a theology . That is why the church produces culture , but is not herself culture . The purpose of the church is to guide man towards uncreated words and uncreated thoughts , but her experience is described in terms of created elements taken from the environment .
Speaker 1In the first millennium , there was one unified tradition in both East and West , with certain minor differences , but gradually they are developed in the West , scholastic theology , which gave preeminence not to the noose but to reason , logic . Those who followed this way rejected the method of the knowledge of God , which is purification , illumination , theosis , that is to say , they rejected orthodox Hezikism and confined themselves to logical speculation about God and to many false doctrines . Thereafter , the reformers appeared and rejected scholastic theology and arrived at a certain moralism . So we have on the one side the scholasticism of the Roman Catholics and on the other side the moralizing of Protestantism .
Speaker 1The orthodox tradition is inextricably intertwined with Hezikism , the tradition of prayer and stillness , which is the method by which we may come to the knowledge of God . Father Sophrony used to say that if we pay careful attention to the holy scriptures , we will notice that every manifestation of God , every theophany , is preceded by prayer and stillness . So Hezikia , prayer and stillness , is the prerequisite for man's encounter with God . Now I realize that in identifying these 10 points , it's not possible to cover such a vast array of themes and topics in sufficient detail in a shorter space of time without raising many , many questions . But it's my hope that by highlighting the points that we've made , we might be challenged to look a little closer at the fundamentals of Christianity from a fresh and hopefully practical perspective . Click on the join button below our video and become a friend or reader of the Mount Tabor Academy . Support our drive to introduce the theology and spiritual life of the Orthodox Church to the wider community . Thank you ,