Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
“Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church”, with Prof. Christopher Veniamin
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present. Available Units thus far:
Unit 1: Introduction: Holy Scripture, Greek Philosophy, Philo of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 2: Irenaeus of Lyons (Season 3)
Unit 3: Clement the Alexandrian (Season 3)
Unit 4: Origen (Season 3)
Unit 5: Athanasius the Great (Season 3)
Unit 6: The Cappadocian Fathers (Season 3)
Unit 7: Augustine of Hippo (Season 3)
Unit 8: John Chrysostom (Season 3)
Unit 9: Cyril of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 14: Gregory Palamas (Season 1)
Unit 15: John of the Ladder (Season 4)
Unit 16: Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites (Season 2)
MISCELLANEOUS
Members-only: Special Editions (Season 5)
Empirical Dogmatics: The Theology of Fr. John Romanides (Season 6)
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies ; and The Enlargement of the Heart, by Archimandrite Zacharias ; Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022) ; The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016) ; The Transfiguration of Christ in Greek Patristic Literature (2022) ; and Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos, Empirical Dogmatics of the Orthodox Catholic Church: According to the Spoken Teaching of Father John Romanides, Vol. 1 (2012), Vol. 2 (repr. ed. 2020).
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the profound interrelationship between Orthodox theology and the Orthodox Christian life, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos contained therein.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: I wish to express my indebtedness to the spoken and written traditions of Sts Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites, Fr. Zacharias Zacharou, Fr. Kyrill Akon, Fr. Raphael Noica, Fr. Symeon Brüschweiler; Fr. John Romanides, Fr. Pavlos Englezakis, Fr. Georges Florovsky, Prof. Constantine Scouteris, Prof. George Mantzarides, Prof. John Fountoulis, Mtp Hierotheos Vlachos, Mtp Kallistos Ware, and Prof. Panayiotes Chrestou. My presentations have been enriched by all of the above sources. Responsibility however for the content of my presentations is of course mine alone. ©Christopher Veniamin 2024
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
Athanasius the Great, Pt. 2: What did Arius Believe? Part 2 “Mystical Theology”, Prof. C. Veniamin
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Series: Mystical Theology
Episode 12: Athanasius the Great, Pt. 2: What did Arius Believe? Part 2
Introducing the theology and spiritual life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present.
In Episode 12 of our “Mystical Theology”, we have Part 2 of our presentation of “Athanasius the Great: What did Arius Believe?”, as a preparation for our overview of St. Athanasius’ defence of the Orthodox Faith against the Arian heresy, which culminates in the glorious proclamation of Christ as true and perfect God by the Council of Nicaea in 325. Some of the themes covered in this podcast are listed in the Timestamps below.
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the interwoven character of theology and Christian living, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos.
Q&As related to Episode 12 available in The Professor’s Blog.
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022): ; The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016); and Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos, Empirical Dogmatics of the Orthodox Catholic Church: According to the Spoken Teaching of Father John Romanides, Vol. 1 (2012), Vol. 2 (repr. ed. 2020).
Join the Mount Thabor Academy Podcasts and help us to bring podcasts on Orthodox theology and the spiritual life to the wider community.
If you enjoy our podcast, consider supporting our The Mount Thabor Academy Patreon page, to unlock exclusive, member-only content.
Print Books by MOUNT THABOR PUBLISHING
eBooks Amazon Kindle
Contact us: info@mountthabor.com
Dr. Christopher Veniamin D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Introduction
Speaker 1So picking up from where we left off last time , looking at surviving fragments of Aeorius' Thalia , chiefly in the works of Saint Athanasius the Great .
Fragment 12 of the Thalia
Speaker 1And there's another fragment , fragment 12 . This fragment is also from Athanasius' Discourses Against the Aereans his first discourse , section 6 , and his Encyclical Letter to the Bishops of Egypt and Libya , again section 12 . That's where this fragment is preserved , for , moreover , the son does not only not know the father precisely . So Aeorius is denying that the son knows the father , because if he knew the father , what would that make him ? That would make him equal with the father . So he denies knowledge of the father by the son , for he is lacking in comprehension . And now Aeorius , who only knows the father precisely , does not know , he is missing this . So , yes , he is lacking in what he is able to contain , how much knowledge he can contain . There's a difference between God and the son of God , the Logos , but the son , this fragment continues the son does not even perceive and he does not even know his own essence . He doesn't know the essence of the father , he doesn't even know his own essence . That's the early Arian argument , and this is the argument that will be easily overturned by the Orthodox , by Saint Athanasius and company , and that's the central component that the later Arians will change . Unomius and company will turn this around and say so what if he knows the essence of the father ? That's no big deal , even we can know the essence of the father Sounds a little bit abstract at this point , but you'll see this coming up again and again in the arguments of Unomius , aetius and company and the responses by Saint Basil , saint Gregory , saint Gregory of Nisa , saint John Chrysostom . Yeah , but for now early Arians are saying the Logos doesn't know the essence of the father , so he cannot be of the same usia , cannot be of the same substance and he doesn't even know his own essence . There's a longer fragment here . This is fragment two .
Speaker 1God himself in his nature is inexpressible to all , aridos , apasin to all . He is ineffable . He alone has no one his equal , nor like him , nor of equal glory . Of course . No equal in essence means that you cannot have equal glory . We call him unbegotten because of him , whose nature is that he is begotten . So they come to the logical conclusion that God must be unbegotten because the Son is begotten . He is the only begotten of the father . So if he's begotten , the father must be , by extrapolation , unbegotten . We praise him as having no beginning because of him who has a beginning . So the father is without beginning , because being begotten , according to the Arians , means that the Logos has a beginning . We revere him as eternal because of him , who was born in time and chrono . I'm not sure about this .
Speaker 1I would be interested to see a critical edition of this text , because one of the things that the Arians objected to quite vociferously was that they tried to make a big deal out of how , although the Son and Word of God is not consubstantial with God the Father , he is a very different being to us , and Arius and company insisted that he was begotten before all ages . I mean , they recognized that the first created thing is the age and that the Logos was produced in order to effect the creation , in order to create . So you have this kind of middle Platonist metaphysical hierarchy where God the One is completely uninvolved in the creation of the world , but his instrument , the Logos , is the One through whom everything is brought into existence . We've seen this , it's already been said in the other fragments , and that means that everything , including the ages , is brought into existence through the Logos . Well , that means before time , because the ages are eternity . Age here means everlasting , and everlasting comes before time . So where it breeds , we revere him as eternal .
Speaker 1Because of him , who was born in time , some kind of explanation is needed . I can imagine the sharper contemporaries asking the Arians questions about the consistency of that point . He , that is without beginning , established the Son as the beginning of things , created Proverbs 822 , the famous key text for the Arians . The Lord created me , the beginning of his ways . He advanced him to be his own son . According to his own proper subsistence , he has nothing that is proper to God . So , according to his own natural being , he has nothing that is natural to God , for he is neither equal nor is he consubstantial .
Speaker 1The word is omousios to him . There is therefore . This is how Fragment 2 concludes . There is therefore a trinity , but not of like glories , because it's a trinity of descending order of rank . There is therefore a trinity , but not of like glories . Their substances and the word used here is the plural and apostasis , their hypotheses are not mingled with each other , and one is more glorious than the other in the immensity of their glories . So you have the third glory , which is not as great as the second glory , which is not as great as the first glory . The Father , according to substance , kadusian , in essence , is alien to the Son because he exists without beginning . Understand that the monad was , but the dyad was not , until it came into existence . No mention of the trinity at this point , because he wants to say wisdom . This is the hypostatic wisdom , in other words , christ wisdom .
Speaker 1The logos came into existence as wisdom at the will of the wise God . This is where the simplicity of the Arian argument breaks down and they begin to lose people On the surface . Arianism is very simple , straightforward and appealing , makes sense there's God and then the Son of God . Yeah , the Son of God must come after , have a beginning , but wisdom came into existence as wisdom at the will of the wise God , by the will of the wise God . Sofu theu thelisi , by the will of the wise God . This is what I'm referring to .
Speaker 1In the final analysis , the Arians had to admit that there were in fact two wisdoms . Because when they were confronted with the argument , are you saying that there was an interval , an instant when God was not wise ? That wisdom came into existence later ? Doesn't that suggest that God was not always wise ? Ah , yes , the Arian said God was always wise . He is wise in himself .
Speaker 1There is the inner wisdom of God , but he brought into existence the logos . Who is the hypostatic wisdom of God ? Because he's going to bring into being the whole creation , and that involves the wisdom of God . So he is wisdom . God is wise and God's wisdom is from everlasting , whereas the hypostatic wisdom has a beginning . Problem is , they had to do the same thing with logos . Are you saying that God brought the hypostatic logos into existence , in which case he himself did not have a logos until such time as the hypostatic logos was begotten ? No , no , no . God has his own inner logos that constitutes his being and that is from everlasting , has no beginning . But there is the hypostatic logos that was brought into existence and does have a beginning . So the logos , the hypostatic logos , the hypostatic wisdom , proved to be a rather difficult argument to promote . It was too complicated and confusing .
Speaker 1And then you
"Hodegos Fragment”, Anastasius the Sinaite & Theology / Economy distinction
Speaker 1might be wondering how on earth do the Aryans deal with the prologue ? The first few lines of the fourth Gospel in the beginning was the word . I'm not sure that this answers the question completely , but the Thalia does take a crack at it , and this is a fragment that's preserved . Not through Athanasius , this is something that is preserved in the writings of Saint Anastasius the Sinait , much later in a work called the Guide Oligos , section 21, . So it's called the Oligos Fragment and it's preserved in Ming Patrologia , graeke 89 , 284 , a is the column number . Admireably does John say so .
Speaker 1The fragment begins in the beginning was the word Logos , john 1 , 1 , that is the spoken word of God , dorema , the spoken word of God , god is speaking . That's the word that is referred to in John 1,1 , for he does not say in the beginning was the Son , but the uttered word , or logos , oproforigos , the expressed word , yes , the uttered word of God , and the areas are taking here from terminology that we do find earlier in early Christian literature . We find oproforigos logos is a term that is found in the early apologists , in Justin the philosopher and martyr , we find it in Theophilus of Antioch , we find it in Athena Gouris . Oproforigos logos as opposed to oproforigos logos , the expressed word , the uttered word , as opposed to the indwelling logos or enviathetos logos , the logos that dwells within God .
Speaker 1Well , during the time of the early apologists there was a tension between the language that they were using and theology , what we call theology proper today , because at that time the language of the apologists focused more on the divine economy . So what they said ? They said in reference to , specifically , the saving work of Christ . With St Athanasius , who responds to the Arians , we have for the first time the distinction between economy , divine economy , and theologia , which refers to God in himself . So there was a clarity that was given by St Athanasius that we did not previously have . In linguistic terms you could see this if you made this distinction somehow . But linguistically it wasn't clear until St Athanasius points out this fundamental distinction that we should be aware of when we are speaking of God going out of himself in his love for mankind , expressed ultimately in the saving work of his incarnation , and then , on the other hand , when we are speaking of God in himself , in Seyibso . So this idea that the logos is actually the rima , literally a word that is spoken from the mouth of God and it's not referring to the hypostatic word at that point , doesn't really jive with the rest of the prologue of the Fourth Gospel . But that did not deter the Arians , who were relentless in pushing their doctrines and I would like to conclude this section , which is not exactly inspiring , to know what they actually said and how they expressed themselves , the early Arians .
Two Letters by Arius
Speaker 1So in concluding this section , I just want to read to you two letters written by Arius himself . The first he writes to his bishop , bishop Alexander , who's not very happy with him , and in that letter he's somewhat guarded in what he says about his doctrine , what he believes , his credo . But in the second letter he's writing to his friend and fellow Lucianists , eusebius of Nicomedia not of Caesarea , but Eusebius of Nicomedia , his fellow Lucianists , and in that letter he's a little more open , as you will see . So let's read these two letters before we take a break . Firstly , the letter to Alexander , bishop of Alexandria , is written around 320 and is preserved in an encyclical concerning the synods or the councils of Rimini in Italy and Seleucia in Isoria , preserved in Athanasius and also in Epiphanius Gage , the heresies 69 , paragraphs 7 to 8 . And the translation into English is from a lecture delivered by Professor Maurice Wiles in Christchurch Oxford University in 1985 or 1986 .
Speaker 1So this is what Arius writes to our blessed pope and Bishop Alexander the presbyters and deacons send greetings in the Lord , our faith from our forefathers , which we have learned also from the blessed pope , is this we acknowledge one God alone , having immortality alone , wise alone , good alone , sovereign judge , governor and administrator of all , unalterable and unchangeable , just and good God of law and prophets and New Testament , who begat and only begotten Son before eternal times , before eternal times , through whom he has made both the ages and the universe and begat him not in semblance but in truth , and that he made him subsist at his own will , unalterable and unchangeable , perfect creature of God , but not as one of the creatures , offspring , but not as one of those of the things that have come into existence . Nor , as Valentine has pronounced , that the offspring of the Father was an issue . Nor , as Manicheus taught , the offspring was a portion , portion of the Father Homocius . This is why they ejected Homocius , because it had been used previously and in a materialistic way . And here Aearius is identifying Manicheus as , using Homocius , that the offspring was a portion of the Father Homocius . Or , as Sibelius , dividing the Monad , speaks of a son and father . Nor , as Hierarchus , of one torch from another . That's interesting because we don't know of a Hierarchus , unless this is a corruption of the name Justin , because St Justin spoke of the divinity being from one torch to another , or as a lamp divided into two . Nor that he who was before was afterwards generated or new created into a son as thou to thyself .
Speaker 1Blessed Pope , in the midst of the church and in session , has often condemned , but , as we say , at the will of God , created before times and before ages , and gaining life and being and his glories from the Father who gave real existence to those together with him . For the Father did not , in giving to him the inheritance of all things , deprive himself of what he has in generately in himself , for he is the fountain of all things . Thus there are three hypotheses . And God , being the cause of all things , is unbegun and altogether soul . But the son , being begotten apart from time by the Father and being created and found before ages , was not before his generation , but being begotten apart from time , before all things alone was made to subsist by the Father . For he is not eternal or co-eternal or co-unoriginate with the Father , nor has he his being together with the Father , as some speak of relations introducing two in-generate beginnings . But God is before all things as being monad and beginning of all . And now he concludes his as you can see , it's an apologia to his bishop Wherefore also he is before the Son , as we have learned also from thy preaching in the midst of the church , even as then , from God he has his being and glories and life and all things are delivered unto him . In such sense is God his origin . But if the terms from him and from the womb and I came forth from the Father and I come be understood by some to mean as if a part of him being homoousios or as an issue , then the Father is , according to them , compounded and divisible and alterable and material and , as far as concerns them , undergoes what is appropriate to a body who is the incorporeal God . That's where the letter ends . So it's pretty clear . All the things that we have mentioned so far are there . Begotten for arius means that the sun has a beginning , but God as God does not .
Speaker 1So in his letter to Eusebius , bishop of Nicomedia , also written around 320 , the same year , and survives in Theodoretus , ecclesiastical History , 15 , and in Epiphanius , 16 , against the heresies 69 , 60 , a shorter letter but nevertheless another testimony from Arius himself as to what he believed . To his very dear Lord , the faithful man of God Orthodox , eusebius Arius , unjustly persecuted by Pope Alexander on account of that all-conquering truth , which you also defend , as with a shield , sends greeting in the Lord . As Amonius , my father was going to Nicomedia . I thought it right and my bounden duty to greet you by him and also to make mention of that inborn love and kindly disposition which you bear towards the brethren . For the sake of God and of his Christ , I want to tell you that the bishop makes great havoc of us and persecutes us severely and is in full sale against us . He has driven us out of the city as atheists because we do not concur in what he publicly preaches , namely that God has always been and the Son has always been . Father and Son exist together . The Son has his existence unbegotten , along with God ever being begotten , begotten of the unbegotten or unbegottenly begotten . God does not precede the Son by thought or by any interval , however small . God has always been . The Son has always been . The Son is from God himself . Eusebius , your brother in Caesarea , theodotus , paulinus , athanasius , gregory , aetius that has to be another , a different Athanasius , by the way .
Speaker 1And all the bishops of the east have been made anathema because they say that God has existence without beginning prior to his Son , except Philogonius , helanicus and Macarius , who are heretical fellows and uncatacized . One of them says that the Son is a fusion , another that he is an emission , another that he is also unbegotten . These are empires to which we could not listen , even though the heretics should threaten us with a thousand deaths . But as for us , what do we say and believe and what have we taught ? And what do we teach ?
Speaker 1So here comes a few lines of what summarizes the Arian position that the Son is not unbegotten , nor in any way part of the unbegotten , nor from some lower essence , that is , from matter , but that by his own will and counsel he has subsisted before time and before ages as God full of grace and truth , only begotten , unchangeable .
Speaker 1So he grants him all of those characteristics and that he was not , before he was , begotten , or created or purposed or established , for he was not unbegotten . We are persecuted because we say the Son had a beginning , but God is without beginning . This is really the cause of our persecution . And likewise because we say that he is from nothing and this we say because he is neither part of God nor of any lower essence , for this are we persecuted . The rest you know . Farewell in the Lord , as a fellow disciple of Lucian and as a truly pious man , as your name implies , saviour , remember our afflictions .
Conclusion
Speaker 1So in our next presentation we shall turn to St Athanasius' response that Christ is or on that . He is consubstantial with God , the Father , and , in his divinity , perfectly equal to him and differs only according to hypostasis . He is the Son and Word of God , but in no way is he subordinate to the Father in his divine status .