Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
“Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church”, with Prof. Christopher Veniamin
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present. Available Units thus far:
Unit 1: Introduction: Holy Scripture, Greek Philosophy, Philo of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 2: Irenaeus of Lyons (Season 3)
Unit 3: Clement the Alexandrian (Season 3)
Unit 4: Origen (Season 3)
Unit 5: Athanasius the Great (Season 3)
Unit 6: The Cappadocian Fathers (Season 3)
Unit 7: Augustine of Hippo (Season 3)
Unit 8: John Chrysostom (Season 3)
Unit 9: Cyril of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 14: Gregory Palamas (Season 1)
Unit 15: John of the Ladder (Season 4)
Unit 16: Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites (Season 2)
MISCELLANEOUS
Members-only: Special Editions (Season 5)
Empirical Dogmatics: The Theology of Fr. John Romanides (Season 6)
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies ; and The Enlargement of the Heart, by Archimandrite Zacharias ; Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022) ; The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016) ; The Transfiguration of Christ in Greek Patristic Literature (2022) ; and Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos, Empirical Dogmatics of the Orthodox Catholic Church: According to the Spoken Teaching of Father John Romanides, Vol. 1 (2012), Vol. 2 (repr. ed. 2020).
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the profound interrelationship between Orthodox theology and the Orthodox Christian life, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos contained therein.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: I wish to express my indebtedness to the spoken and written traditions of Sts Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites, Fr. Zacharias Zacharou, Fr. Kyrill Akon, Fr. Raphael Noica, Fr. Symeon Brüschweiler; Fr. John Romanides, Fr. Pavlos Englezakis, Fr. Georges Florovsky, Prof. Constantine Scouteris, Prof. George Mantzarides, Prof. John Fountoulis, Mtp Hierotheos Vlachos, Mtp Kallistos Ware, and Prof. Panayiotes Chrestou. My presentations have been enriched by all of the above sources. Responsibility however for the content of my presentations is of course mine alone. ©Christopher Veniamin 2024
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
Gregory Palamas: Iconography & Knowledge of God through Prayer (Better Sound Quality), Episode 4bis, Prof. C. Veniamin
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Unit 14: St. Gregory Palamas: An Introduction, Prof. Christopher Veniamin
Episode 4bis: Iconography & Knowledge of God through Prayer (Better Sound Quality)
Episode 4bis of “Gregory Palamas: An Introduction” is mainly an enhanced sound quality version of the original episode (with new title credits at the beginning, and an end card, plus an appeal for support tagged on at the end), which introduces the "Hesychast Controversy" of the 14th century in the declining decades of the Christian Roman Empire. What was Hesychasm really all about? And why is it still relevant to us today in the 21st century?
In this fourth part, we discuss the accusation of Iconoclasm leveled against the Hesychasts, and Prayer as the chief means by which knowledge of God is attained.
The main themes covered in this presentation are included in the Timestamps below.
Q&As related to Episode 4 available in The Professor’s Blog.
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022); The Transfiguration of Christ in Greek Patristic Literature (2022); and The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016).
Join the Mount Thabor Academy Podcasts and help us to bring podcasts on Orthodox theology and the spiritual life to the wider community.
If you enjoy our podcast, consider supporting our The Mount Thabor Academy Patreon page, to unlock exclusive, member-only content.
Print Books by MOUNT THABOR PUBLISHING
eBooks Amazon Kindle
Contact us: info@mountthabor.com
Dr. Christopher Veniamin D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Accusation of iconoclasm
Speaker 1Now , regarding the accusation of iconoclasm , and despite the total lack of evidence suggesting the Hesychasts were negatively disposed towards icons , it seems that Palamas's opponents started from a theoretical premise and there seems to be also a practical reason behind their regarding the Hesychasts as iconoclasts . The theoretical premise would have been that if Hesychasts were Massalians , then they would also be against icons . Because the Massalians were against icons . Every Massalian was an iconoclast by definition . Gregoras himself accuses the Hesychasts of being iconoclasts and of burning icons , and that's a rather fantastic accusation . He says that among the Massalians on Athos was George of Larissa , joseph the Cretan and Moses the painter . So Gregorius wants us to believe that Moses the painter , or Zografos , the painter of icons , used to burn his own icons . None of this makes much sense , but , as we mentioned earlier , perhaps there was a more practical reason as to why the Hezekiahs were regarded as iconoclasts by their opponents . Of course , the Hezekiahs were not like the Massalians , who rejected icons , since they were able to see God with their physical eyes . And since they were able to see God with their physical eyes , and since they were able to see God in this way , what need could there have possibly been for icons in the first place for a Massalian . How exactly they saw God . However , the Massalians never say , the Massalians never say , but the Hesychasts , it would seem , were against naturalist representations in icons . We said this before , but it bears repeating .
Speaker 1At that time , the famous Macedonian school of art so-called these names don't always help you , but the Macedonian school of art was in its prime and it was based on the style or the chief exponent of which
Panselinos and the Macedonian School
Speaker 1was the great Panselinos . His name means full moon . Now , panselinos was a brilliant iconographer and you can see his iconography in the cathedral church of Mount Athos in the capital , caries . His wall paintings are exquisite , they are remarkable . This is the famous Protaton of Caries . We see his work at Vatobedi and also at other monasteries on the Holy Mountain . It does seem that this style was not appreciated by the Hesychasts of the 14th century . Why ? Why were the hesychasts not attracted by this beautiful , wonderful iconographic style of Panselinos ?
Speaker 1When you look at the examples of the Macedonian school , the iconography of Panselinos , of the Macedonian school , the iconography of Panselinos , take a look at the dynamic faces , the prosopography In the frescoes of the Protaton , take a look at those of Christ , of St John the Theologian and others , which were written by Pancelinos himself , and there you will find dramatic movement , expression and the use of natural colors in the countenances of the saints portrayed . Pancelinos was first and foremost a prosopographer . Now take a look and compare the style of Pansellinos and that of the depiction of another iconographer , this time an iconographer who became
Feofan Grek and the Cretan School
Speaker 1known in Russian as Theophanes the Greek , who went to Russia in the mid-14th century and who develops a style which is an expression of hesychasm . Take a look at his famous icon of Macarius the Egyptian , macarius the Great , theophanes the Greek . We said before we have two El Grecos in history . We have the El Greco who went to Spain in the 16th century , el Greco who went to Spain in the 16th century , whose name was Dominikos Theotokopoulos and Theophan Grec . The other El Greco went to Russia approximately two centuries earlier and both of them brought the spirit of Hezekasm to the places where they flourished . The Hezekasm of El Greco , the El Greco of the West , was very different and could not be accepted in its 14th century form . The first El Greco went to Russia and became probably the greatest iconographer in Russian history and , as I'm sure you know , he was the teacher of Andrei Roblov .
Speaker 1So in his famous icon of Macarius the Egyptian Macarius the Great , we have a dark background with a barely discernible face in the middle , which is also rather dark and using colors that are not natural , but at various points , such as from the saint's beard , we see thin lines of light . These are illuminations , these are rays , rays of light , they are rays of the divine light . We don't see any of this in the style of Panselinos . These are the rays which shine forth from God in his divine energies , and it is then the energies of God that lend expression to the prosopography of Theophanes the Greek Phelphangrek . It's clear , moreover , that this style of iconography comes from Mount Athos and indeed from the Hesychast tradition . Of course , the names Macedonian school , cretan school , as this style is often referred to , are misnomers . Really , they're a little misleading . Both of the styles referred to above are products of Constantinople and Mount Athos .
Speaker 1Now , here it should be noted that Theophanes the Greek was sent to Russia by a particular person
Patriarch Philotheos Kokkinos
Speaker 1, philotheos Kokinos , in 1374 , and he did this deliberately . He was sent there much in the same way as bishops and abbots and others were sent , and , as an iconographer , feofan was able to penetrate and influence in many and various ways . In other words , he was sent with the express purpose of conveying the spirit of hesychasm as a bearer of the hesychast spirit , and it is a fact that , from the middle of the 14th century onwards , there is nothing in the church that is not deeply influenced by the Hesychast tradition . So let us turn now to some of the gnosiological aspects of the Hesychast controversy , and specifically to the knowledge of God .
Speaker 1As St Gregory used to say
Two forms of knowledge
Speaker 1, there's human knowledge and then there's divine knowledge , and the amazing thing about human knowledge is that it boils down to the same thing and I know that's a long story , I know you have the whole history of ideas . Ultimately , human knowledge searches for the essence of things , so it's essentialist in character . It's interesting that human reason , left to its own devices , the human dhyānya , wants to discover what a thing is , no matter what that thing may be In philosophical terms . You either tend towards a Platonic view of the scheme of things or you tend towards an Aristotelian , and there are different shades between the two poles . These are the two poles of human knowledge , though , and they've been described in different ways by different cultures and they have their own characteristics , but ultimately , it's all about what is reality . The human mind can only go so far , and it's limited by its rational approach to things , even when it attempts to be supra-rational , even when it tries to be apophatic in the philosophical sense . For example
Filioque
Speaker 1, balaam actually argues against the Filioque . When he argues against the Filioque , his argument is the Latins are wrong to introduce the Filioque because ultimately we don't know what the Filioque means . That's why St Gregory , when he writes his two treatises against the Filioque , he calls them demonstrations . St Gregory's demonstrations do have a philosophical dimension inasmuch as he presents a reasonable argumentation , but his treatises are ultimately based on the experience of the saints . It's not a philosophical argumentation .
Speaker 1I've been involved in examinations at the doctoral level where I was the external examiner and the other three examiners were Roman Catholics and they really were upset when this PhD candidate was trying to follow the orthodox line and saying this is not rational , this cannot be understood rationally or philosophically . The three examiners there were saying then , what's left ? What is left ? There's nothing left . Take away the rational , we have nothing . That's what they really
Empirical basis of theology
Speaker 1believe , because they're not aware of the empirical aspect . The empirical basis , not just the aspect , but the basis of biblical and patristic theology is empirical . It's based on experience . We experience God through our noetic principle , noetic faculty , and then we have the ability to describe that . The description is where the use of our reason comes in , but that description still cannot convey by itself the experience . So there's a tension between the experience and the description of the experience , because to understand the experience presupposes some experience .
Speaker 1The approach of Gregoras represents the philosophical mindset found among certain intellectuals
Byzantine renaissance
Speaker 1during the Byzantine Renaissance of this period . This is the Renaissance that actually influenced the Italian Renaissance . So it's interesting how , when you take a philosophical or conceptual approach to these questions , you end up with the same basic conclusions , because by taking that approach , you have already assumed a set of presuppositions that will determine your conclusions . It sounds a bit abstract . I'll make it a bit more concrete . I'll try to explain to you
"Analogia entis" — "Analogia fidei"
Speaker 1how there's no analogia entis and there's no analogia fide in the Orthodox tradition because , on the one hand , the analogia entis is based not on the created-uncreated distinction , but it's based on the philosophical distinction between spirit and matter , which became the primary distinction in the West , instead of the created-uncreated , even though in the 14th century in the West
William of Occam and Scholasticism
Speaker 1, william of Ockham attacked the platonic basis of scholasticism and almost destroyed it .
Speaker 1He made the argument that if we were supposed to believe , as the scholastics taught , that all the ideas , the ideas of everything , were in the mind of God , then that would mean that there would be good ideas or better ideas in the mind of God and worse ideas . If we are to believe that there are worse ideas in the mind of God , then that means that in the very being of God there is imperfection . How can imperfection exist in God ? Because the scholastics , taking the platonic approach , generally speaking , thought of God as a kind of architect who had the ideas in his mind for everything that existed , the plan , the pattern , and then he implemented the plans of everything that you see . But if some of what you see is good and some of what you see is not good , where does the not good come from ? Those lesser ideas ? If they're in the mind of God , they mean that God contains imperfection . Quite a simple argument in the end , but it threatened to destroy the whole structure of scholasticism
Luther and “sola scriptura”
Speaker 1and Thomism .
Speaker 1Luther followed Occam on these questions . Can we know God through the creation ? And this argument took away the analogia entis , it took away philosophy and it said only revelation , only by revelation can we know God , and by revelation Luther and his followers understood Holy Scripture . So only Holy Scripture can give you knowledge of God . Sola Scriptura , not Analogia Entis , only Analogia Fide .
Speaker 1But in the Orthodox tradition
No analogies in Orthodox tradition
Speaker 1there's no Analogia Fide either , because there's no similarity between God and creation on the one hand , analogia Entis , and there's no similarity between God and the words and images that are contained on the pages of the Holy Scriptures . It's a language , it's a holy book , but it's only holy when there's a life connected to it , there's an experience connected to it . By itself
Illumination
Speaker 1, it is not illumination . If you look carefully , in the tradition of the Reformers illumination is reading scripture . That's how they understand illumination . And in the Roman Catholic tradition it's scripture and it's also studying the world . That's illumination . So illumination either way becomes intellectual Because even if you just limit it to a book , actually analogia comes in through the back door anyway , because you're suggesting that there's a similarity between the words of Scripture and God himself .
Speaker 1So the difficulty is that when you look at the Orthodox tradition from a Western standpoint , you are looking for your reference point ,
"Authority"
Speaker 1you are looking for your authority , auctoritas . Where do you look , auctoritas ? Where do you look ? So there's a tension between the experience and the description of the experience . That's the difficult . We feel very uncomfortable because we again , the human mind wants to put things in nice , neat , manageable categories and the orth Orthodox faith says no , it doesn't have anything to do with that . It has to do with repentance . It has to do with humility , christ-like humility . It has to do with who loves God the most . Who is a greater saint , the patriarch or a simple lay person In the Orthodox tradition . Well , it depends on who loves God the most . There's no ontological difference between the patriarch and the lay person . What we have said demonstrates and the layperson
Similarities between Barlaam and Gregoras
Speaker 1. What we have said demonstrates why there are similarities between a Gregoras and a Balaam and that , whatever differences they might have in the details of their critique , the fact is that both of them are not coming from within the orthodox tradition .
Speaker 1To the questions that they're trying to to address again , the approach is the same . What is different ? The details . There are some significant quote-unquote differences in detail . But in response to the Eunomian question , what did the Cappadocian fathers say ?
Same response given to the Arians
Speaker 1And in response to the early Arians , what did Athanasius appeal to when he said to Arius , who told you this has anything to do with Aristotle ? When he said to Arius , who told you this has anything to do with Aristotle ? Athanasius , who comes from the tradition of the desert , right with Saint Anthony , the Cappadocians who appeal to the mystery experience of God , saint John Chrysostom , the same , and we see now people coming out of a similar set of presuppositions arguing against St Gregory's defense
Knowledge of God through prayer
Speaker 1of the tradition of the church . Knowledge of God , it's about prayer . How do we know God ? We pray In the Orthodox tradition we pray . We don't think our way , we pray , we worship , and that teaches us everything we need to know .
Speaker 1But first take a look , if you will , at the homilies of St Gregory Palamas , in which is contained all of his ascetico-theological vision . So I would suggest that you read Homily 53 , on the entry of the Mother of God into the Holy of Holies ,
Mother of God archetypal hesychast
Speaker 1wherein he presents the Mother of God as the archetypal hesychast , the model of hesychasm , and pay especial attention to the notes that accompany that homily . It is in fact today a theological treatise . Saint Gregory originally wrote it as his homily on the entry of the Mother of God into the Holy of Holies and it was preserved as such . But he worked on it over the years and it turned into a treatise . So it's about three times the length of a long homily by St Gregory and there is a lot to it . It's a wonderful hymn to the Mother of God , it's a prayer . It's a prayer to the Mother of God , it's an offering to her in language which is , quite frankly , astounding . But he also pushes the language of theology to its very limits . And in his description of what the mother of god accomplished when she entered the holy of holies , what was that about ? About what did she do there ? What happened to her ?
Speaker 1And you'll find there , as I said , very important points which will help you to understand the whole ascetic ethos of the Hesychasts , of those people , in other words , who represent the life of prayer . When we say , for example , that this was a remarkable period , we had a series of three or four patriarchs of Constantinople who were hesychasts , were hesychasts what that means is not just that they belong to a certain party or a group of people who espoused certain theories and who strove to impose their way of thinking on others , to impose their way of thinking on others . What that
Patriarchs men of prayer
Speaker 1means is that we had a series of patriarchs , one after another , who were men of prayer . They were men of prayer , and you know what ? That transformed the whole of that period into something amazing . It transformed the whole period into something majestic .
Speaker 1But not only that . The legacy that that produced is with us to this very day . It's a wonderful thing . We know from St Simeon the New Theologian and others the challenges that we have in the life of the Church , that we are not just bishops , but we are not what we should be , and if we were , the whole world would change . The whole world would be transformed if we were truly disciples of Christ .
Speaker 1And this period in the life of the church , in the history of the church , the real history of the church , the history of the saints , has had a tremendous impact . I mentioned just one example last week the effect of sending Feofan Grek into the rushes and thereby transmitting the whole spirit and ethos of the life of prayer throughout the Slav lands . Such was the influence of Felfan Greg . So tremendously important to appreciate this when we have leaders who are men of prayer . Look at what happens . Look at how wonderful it is that the church truly becomes a paradise on earth and many blessings are bestowed upon all the members of the body of Christ . Click on the Support the Show button in the description box and become a supporter of the Mount Tabor Academy podcasts , which aim to introduce the theology and spiritual life of the Orthodox Church to the wider community .