Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
“Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church”, with Prof. Christopher Veniamin
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present. Available Units thus far:
Unit 1: Introduction: Holy Scripture, Greek Philosophy, Philo of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 2: Irenaeus of Lyons (Season 3)
Unit 3: Clement the Alexandrian (Season 3)
Unit 4: Origen (Season 3)
Unit 5: Athanasius the Great (Season 3)
Unit 6: The Cappadocian Fathers (Season 3)
Unit 7: Augustine of Hippo (Season 3)
Unit 8: John Chrysostom (Season 3)
Unit 9: Cyril of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 14: Gregory Palamas (Season 1)
Unit 15: John of the Ladder (Season 4)
Unit 16: Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites (Season 2)
MISCELLANEOUS
Members-only: Special Editions (Season 5)
Empirical Dogmatics: The Theology of Fr. John Romanides (Season 6)
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies ; and The Enlargement of the Heart, by Archimandrite Zacharias ; Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022) ; The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016) ; The Transfiguration of Christ in Greek Patristic Literature (2022) ; and Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos, Empirical Dogmatics of the Orthodox Catholic Church: According to the Spoken Teaching of Father John Romanides, Vol. 1 (2012), Vol. 2 (repr. ed. 2020).
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the profound interrelationship between Orthodox theology and the Orthodox Christian life, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos contained therein.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: I wish to express my indebtedness to the spoken and written traditions of Sts Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites, Fr. Zacharias Zacharou, Fr. Kyrill Akon, Fr. Raphael Noica, Fr. Symeon Brüschweiler; Fr. John Romanides, Fr. Pavlos Englezakis, Fr. Georges Florovsky, Prof. Constantine Scouteris, Prof. George Mantzarides, Prof. John Fountoulis, Mtp Hierotheos Vlachos, Mtp Kallistos Ware, and Prof. Panayiotes Chrestou. My presentations have been enriched by all of the above sources. Responsibility however for the content of my presentations is of course mine alone. ©Christopher Veniamin 2024
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
Gregory Palamas: Triumph of Ascetic Theology Over Philosophical Speculation (Better Sound Quality), Episode 6bis, Prof. C. Veniamin
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Unit 14: St. Gregory Palamas: An Introduction, Prof. Christopher Veniamin
Episode 6bis: Triumph of Ascetic Theology Over Philosophical Speculation (Better Sound Quality)
Episode 6bis of “Gregory Palamas: An Introduction” is mainly an *enhanced sound quality* version of the original episode (with new title credits at the beginning, and an end card, plus an appeal for support tagged on at the end), which introduces the "Hesychast Controversy" of the 14th century in the declining decades of the Christian Roman Empire.
The sixth episode presents the differing perspectives of Palamas’ three theological opponents, Barlaam, Akindynus and Gregoras, who curiously shared a common intellectualistic approach to matters theological, which gradually, since Augustine of Hippo, became the fundamental approach of the West: philosophical speculation.
Themes covered in this episode include why the essence-energies distinction is not ditheism; Palamas’ disarming distinction between “Antilogia” and “Homologia”; St. Gregory held hostage by the Ottoman Turkss in 1354; and the outcome of Palamas’ discussion with the Turkish Mullah.
Q&As related to Episode 6 available in The Professor’s Blog.
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022); The Transfiguration of Christ in Greek Patristic Literature (2022); and The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016).
Join the Mount Thabor Academy Podcasts and help us to bring podcasts on Orthodox theology and the spiritual life to the wider community.
If you enjoy our podcast, consider supporting our The Mount Thabor Academy Patreon page, to unlock exclusive, member-only content.
Print Books by MOUNT THABOR PUBLISHING
eBooks Amazon Kindle
Contact us: info@mountthabor.com
Dr. Christopher Veniamin D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Theological Debates
Speaker 1What are the different phases of these theological debates ? We know that Balaam had his own perspective , echidnos had his , gregoras had his . Don't forget that when Balaam dialogues with the West , when he writes against the Filioque , he's basically an agnostic . There's no direct revelation in agnosticism . Balaam's biggest problem was his being scandalized at the way the body was included in the prayer of the hesychasts , navel gazersers and so on . And in fact his first encounter was with simple monks who really were not articulate at all about the life of prayer . Whatever they did , they pressed the wrong buttons , they said the wrong words and the wrong buttons , they said the wrong words and Balaam was scandalized . Balaam actually went to Patriarch John Callicus and said to him this is what these people are teaching . Would you give me your blessing and let me take care of them ? And Patriarch John Callicus was one of those churchmen who was not interested in theology and he said look , you don't have my blessing to start a polemic against these people . Let sleeping dogs lie . Let's not blow up this to something more than it is . Just stay away from it . Stay calm , which of course Balaam did up to a point , but not really because he started writing against the Hesychasts . And when St Gregory Palamas found out that he was doing this and he didn't actually have the books that Balaam had written himself , but he had heard what he was saying he started to write in defense of the holy Hesychasts . And it was only later that , when Balaam had responded to Palamas' criticisms so there was this correspondence of a polemic debate that he began to call them Massalians and go into more detail , and then Palamas went into more specific details himself , because then he got hold of the actual books and saw what Balaam was saying , and so on and so forth .
Speaker 1Balaam was scandalized by the inclusion of the body , because his vision of the scheme of things , the spiritual life , was the spirit . He was very , actually Augustinian in this regard . He didn't know what to do with the body . He just assumed the body should have nothing to do Because , as Barlam would say , following a Platonist line of thinking , anything composite is incapable of the real life . That's Plato . The life of the spiritual world in the place above the heavens , plato's Dobos Iberuranios is for spirits . There's no place for the body , the stuff out of which the furniture of the world is made , as Plato would say . The unfortunate union of the spirit with the body during this earthly existence of ours , impedes our communion with reality , with the ultimate and supreme being , which is spiritual , spiritual . And in this world of conjecture , opinion beasties faith . This is a world which doesn't give you sure knowledge . Sure knowledge , as Augustine wrongly says , comes in the life , hereafter Spiritual knowledge . So in Balaam , on the one hand you have the problem of the body . Then you have the question how does God reveal himself ? Well , balaam would say through created symbols and images . This is pure Augustinianism .
Speaker 1Therefore , when Balaam is arguing against the Latins and their filioque , he's saying why would you want to add something to the creed whose meaning you know nothing about ? You don't know what filioque means anyway , so why do you want to add it ? What difference does it make ? That's Palamas . Gregory Akindinos had been a disciple of Palamas and during the period between 1337-38 and 1341 , where you have this exchange of correspondence between Balaam and Palamas , akindinos tries to play a pacifying role , the role of a peacemaker . In so doing , we see that he actually agrees with Balaam on one basic point and therefore disagrees with Palamas on that point , and then agrees with Palamas on another point and therefore disagrees with Balaam . So he's somewhere in the middle .
Speaker 1What does Akindinos agree with Palamas about the veracity of the prayer this was the prayer life of the church , the hesychasts were not inventing something new and certainly the inclusion of the body . The main issue with Balaam is abundantly attested to in both scripture and tradition . When we make the sign of the cross , when we make prostrations , this is a form of prayer , this is part of our prayer life and it signifies , among other things , that in our effort , we need to make an effort actually in order to come into contact with God . God wants us to make an effort , not just intellectually , but in a way that includes every aspect of our existence , body as well as soul . With the body we take ourselves to church and with the body we stand , we sit , we process , we make prostrations , sign of the cross , as we said , and so forth . So , yes , this is not something new .
Speaker 1Why Balaam was so scandalized by it is another question , why it was unacceptable to him To that degree , because I think we could say , in all fairness to St Augustine , no-transcript . Balaam had this incredible intellectualistic understanding of things , including the spiritual life , really , really extreme . What was the point on which Akindinos and Balaam agreed ? Akindinos' point was that Gregory Palamas was pushing things a bit too far when he claimed that this distinction has always been there in the life of the church , in scripture , in the writings of the fathers not always expressed in the same words , but certainly the meaning is clear that there is that aspect of God which we can never know , the never-to-be-known essence of God , and that aspect of God which we do know , and we can know fully , but fully in the sense , not that comprehend , but that we experience , that this is an experience of God himself , that aspect of God which comes down to us , which Saint John Christos describes in terms of God's condescension . That Akindinos said was pushing things just a little too far . We have already pointed out that in the writings of St Simeon the New Theologian sometimes you see that , but sometimes you don't and Palamas' argument was , of course , that it is there , despite what you see at times , indicating that , for example , simeon sometimes says that we know the essence of God . Saint Peter says we've become partakers of the divine nature . There it is .
Speaker 1So Akindinos was dealt with in the second council in Constantinople in 1347 , and there he was obliged , after losing the debate again to Palamas , to retract his opinions , which he did . By the way , balaam did the same in June of 1341 . You know that was a council of one day . That council took place on one day , and in that one day , the then we call him the prime minister , the great domesticus John Cantacuzinos , who became emperor a little later . He was on the side of Balaam , and when he heard the debate between Balaam and Balaam , balaam referred to him and he said I need your support and I need your advice . I need your support and I need your advice . What do I do ? Because he realized that the Council of 1341 , which was comprised of Emperor Andronicus III , patriarch John Callicus , bishops , senators , people of the city this was a well-attended council , albeit for one day , but they all heard what St Gregory Palamas said , and in response to his friend , the person that Cantacuzinos was protecting , balam Cantacuzinos said to him look , I think it's time for you to apologize to these people and just humbly retreat . It's obvious that these people are wiser in these matters than you are . Just humble yourself , apologize and finish with it . Balaam actually took his advice and he did that , and that was the end of the council as such , and so they didn't have to publish an official Thomas with the minutes of that council . It was enough for the patriarch to send out an encyclical and to say to the people of the church this matter has been resolved . All of the arguments , the accusations against the hesychasts have been resolved . All of the arguments , the accusations against the Hezekiahs have been resolved and there's no more problem .
The Palamas Council and Its Aftermath
Speaker 1Well , that council took place on June the 10th 1341 , as we said , under the chairmanship of Emperor Andronicus III . So after Kantikosinos advised Barlaam , barlaam took that advice , but in the meantime the council ended peacefully on the same day and no publication was made . Andronicus III , who chaired the council , died just five days after the council took place . He died out of exhaustion , he withdrew from public life and he died on June the 15th 1341 . And so his last public duty was actually the chairing of the council of June the 10th 1341 .
Speaker 1So Balaam , at this point , regrets yielding to Palamas and company , but his change of heart was too late . Palamas' prestige was in the ascendant to such a degree that it was impossible for Balaam to amass the necessary support for a fresh assault on the Hesychasts , realizing that there was no more soil for him to flourish in the empire within just a few days . For him to flourish in the empire , within just a few days , balaam beat a hasty retreat back to Italy , whence he had come 15 years earlier with such dreams and aspirations . Back in Italy , he taught the famous Plutarch Greek , he kept company with other famous intellectuals and he was made bishop of Hierarchus by the Pope , without being at all keen to perform his episcopal responsibilities .
Speaker 1Akindinos does something similar on a lower key . Tindinos does something similar on a lower key . He accepts the decision of the Council of 1347 and signs a document to that effect . But he also , secretly and privately , continues to doubt the veracity of St Gregory's position on the essence energies distinction . Gregoras had different motives . We had mentioned how remarkable it is that the presuppositions of all these theological opponents were so similar , if not the same , and how this goes back ultimately to whether you take a conceptual approach to theology or not .
Speaker 1But Gregoras begins with a certain image of the Hesychasts . He sees them as anti-intellectuals . He sees them as simpletons , ignoramuses , people of little culture and insignificant learning and basically , to put it in a nutshell , he believed that the Hesychasts were against the Renaissance of Greek letters and Gregoras' great desire was to be recognized as the intellectual leader of the empire . So he takes up this battle against Palamas to prove that he is the intellectual leader of what was left of the Christian Roman Empire . And just to recap what we said last time , at the first session of the 1351 Council called , if you remember , on the 28th of May , and now John Cantacuzinos VI was emperor we actually had three emperors at the same time but he chaired the council . It was he who posed those six questions , very astute questions , in that fifth and final session , but I'll come to that in a moment .
Speaker 1At the first session , which began on the 28th of May , the anti-Hezekasts accused Palamas and company of diatheism . If you remember , this was one of the criticisms that Akindinos had leveled against Palamas' essence , energies distinction . Not only that , it was not there in the tradition of the church , but his separation of essence and energy in the singular , or essence and energies in the plural , constituted a belief , basically , in two divinities , one higher and one lower . The higher , the never-to-be-known essence , and the lower , the energy or energies which come down to us , using the language of St Basil the Great in letter 234 of the Brazilian collection . So he's accused again , this time by Gregoras and company , of separating the divine energy from the divine essence .
Speaker 1And St Gregory Palamas spends that time after hearing extensive accusations against him , defending himself and the Hesychasts on that point , refutes the accusations of Gregoras and company by means of drawing a distinction between antilogia and homologia , debating and confessing Gregoras and company . Antihesikas said when you were making your confession , you said this and you said that and you were separating the two . And St Gregory is saying when I said this or that , I was responding to something that you had said . This was not a confession of faith . This was a dialogue , a discussion , a debate , and in that , a debate and in that you respond to what's being said and you may take things to a certain point which you wouldn't want to say if you were making a confession , where , in a confession , you balance your words , weigh them very carefully and you make sure that what you're saying is orthodox in every way , with the least possibility of misunderstanding . That's not the case with Andilogia . This was a brilliant distinction and it disarmed Gregoras and company .
Speaker 1During the third session , the anti-Hesychasts of Gregoras protested that they were not supporters of Balaam Because again , they seem to be saying all the things that Balaam had previously said . They wanted to disassociate themselves from Balaam and his position . Well , in fact , as we said , ultimately , in the final analysis , they seem to share much more in common than they like to think . And later , towards the end of June , john Cantacuzins calls a fifth session and submits his six questions in order to bring the Council to a conclusion . In order to bring the council to a conclusion .
Speaker 1So Gregoras is confined to Cora Monastery following 1351 . He's given a lot of freedom and he writes and he complains , and he writes his history and says how he was mistreated by everyone at the council , misunderstood . He wasn't well . Palamas won , but he should never have been allowed to win . A lot of complaints on the part of Gregoras . Gregoras lost against Palamas again in a debate that took place in the palace because Palamas' arguments again were simply more convincing .
Speaker 1Palamas returns to Thessalonica in 1355 and remains there until his death , and many of his surviving homilies were written during this period . In April 1368 , some nine years later , after Palamas had reposed in the Lord , he was proclaimed a saint . His name was inscribed in the calendar of Hagia Sophia , which means essentially that his sanctity was recognized for the entire church , and by placing his commemoration on the second Sunday of Lent as an extension of the Sunday of Orthodoxy , as an extension of the Sunday of Orthodoxy . His memory is celebrated with great reverence throughout the Orthodox world . Patriarch Philotheos himself composed an encomium and a service for him , as well as writing his biography . So I just wanted to say that as a basic recap about the three theological opponents , their similarities , their differences and what basically happened .
Speaker 1There are many remarkable episodes in the life of St Gregory . One of them is when he was taken hostage by the Ottoman Turks in 1354 for about a year . So I would like to add this brief section to our overview in order to present a fuller picture of how much Palamas was able to accomplish in times of great trouble and turmoil . It's incredible what this man managed to achieve . Wherever he was , he was taken from city to city . He went from Lampsakos to Pegas , prusa , nicaea . He was dragged around by the Turks as a hostage . Wherever he went and each place he went , by divine providence he ministered to the other Christian hostages and also those now subjugated to the Turks . During this time , he had the opportunity to have conversations with the Muslims on religion , and one such discussion with the enigmatic Kiones C-H-I-O-N-E-S . This was arranged by the Turkish emir himself , whose name was Orhan .
Speaker 1Palamas observed that almost all of Asia Minor and Mesopotamia was already in the hands of the Turks and he could see that they were now moving into European lands . It seemed that Palamas had been convinced by all this that it was only a matter of time before the remaining parts of the empire would also be taken . And the only practical solution to the impending doom this is interesting he said the only answer is to proselytize the Turks , convert them to Christianity , and this was his regret that we didn't do that . We had the opportunity . Of course , it's very difficult when the person you're trying to proselytize has a sword aimed at your throat , but that's the challenge , and Palamas knew this . He said there's no way we are going to stem this tide . Consequently , palamas agreed to meet with the mullah Tasiman and he said to Tasiman , after long discussions with him , which basically didn't get very far , that he hoped that the time would come when both sides would agree , and he prayed that that time would come soon . And each of them , of course , had his own understanding of what the agreement would be . At any rate , from Palamas's standpoint , that time never came . On the one hand , the leaders of the church , owing to a conjunction of unfavorable circumstances , were not ready for such a great undertaking , while , on the other , the Turks themselves never allowed any initiative in that direction . Every attempt of that kind was simply met with fire and the sword was simply met with fire and the sword .
Speaker 1Now , much has been written about how tolerant the Ottomans were in the earlier years of their conquest . I would merely point out that it is quite clear from the sources that the Islamicization of Asia Minor , for instance , was the result of war , destruction and a form of institutionalized enslavement and fear . In short , it's quite clear that this was not achieved by peaceful means . By peaceful means , and I speak as one whose father is a victim of the developments that took place in Asia Minor . Now , after about a year , orkan freed Palamas , having received huge sums of money as ransom for him . Philotheos tells us that the money was given by Serbian or Dalmatian merchants operating on behalf of Stefan Dusan , who was still hopeful that Palamas would side with him .
Intrigue and Succession in Byzantium
Speaker 1Serbs were taking over the lands of the empire on the western side and the Turks were coming in , of course , chiefly from the east . Gregoras , in his history , tells us that the ransom was paid by Cantacuzenus , who by this time had retired to Cora Monastery and was now known as the monk Joassaf . In the same year , in 1354 , callistos I leaves the throne . Ostrogorsky tells us that this was the result of Callistos protesting against Cantacuzinos' installation of his son Matthew as co-emperor and the directive not to include John Palaeologos in the prayers of the church or in the acclamations at public festival . So Philotheos Cocinos succeeds Callistos at this point . Click on the Support the Show button in the description box and become a supporter of the Mount Tabor Academy podcasts , which aim to introduce the theology and spiritual life of the Orthodox Church to the wider community .