Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
“Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church”, with Prof. Christopher Veniamin
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church, with particular reference to the Holy Bible and the witness of the Church Fathers, past and present. Available Units thus far:
Unit 1: Introduction: Holy Scripture, Greek Philosophy, Philo of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 2: Irenaeus of Lyons (Season 3)
Unit 3: Clement the Alexandrian (Season 3)
Unit 4: Origen (Season 3)
Unit 5: Athanasius the Great (Season 3)
Unit 6: The Cappadocian Fathers (Season 3)
Unit 7: Augustine of Hippo (Season 3)
Unit 8: John Chrysostom (Season 3)
Unit 9: Cyril of Alexandria (Season 3)
Unit 14: Gregory Palamas (Season 1)
Unit 15: John of the Ladder (Season 4)
Unit 16: Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites (Season 2)
MISCELLANEOUS
Members-only: Special Editions (Season 5)
Empirical Dogmatics: The Theology of Fr. John Romanides (Season 6)
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies ; and The Enlargement of the Heart, by Archimandrite Zacharias ; Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022) ; The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016) ; The Transfiguration of Christ in Greek Patristic Literature (2022) ; and Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos, Empirical Dogmatics of the Orthodox Catholic Church: According to the Spoken Teaching of Father John Romanides, Vol. 1 (2012), Vol. 2 (repr. ed. 2020).
It is hoped that these presentations will help the enquirer discern the profound interrelationship between Orthodox theology and the Orthodox Christian life, and to identify the ascetic and pastoral significance of the Orthodox ethos contained therein.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: I wish to express my indebtedness to the spoken and written traditions of Sts Silouan and Sophrony the Athonites, Fr. Zacharias Zacharou, Fr. Kyrill Akon, Fr. Raphael Noica, Fr. Symeon Brüschweiler; Fr. John Romanides, Fr. Pavlos Englezakis, Fr. Georges Florovsky, Prof. Constantine Scouteris, Prof. George Mantzarides, Prof. John Fountoulis, Mtp Hierotheos Vlachos, Mtp Kallistos Ware, and Prof. Panayiotes Chrestou. My presentations have been enriched by all of the above sources. Responsibility however for the content of my presentations is of course mine alone. ©Christopher Veniamin 2024
Mystical Theology: Introducing the Theology and Spiritual Life of the Orthodox Church
The Cappadocian Fathers, Part 2: Basil the Great, Gregory the Theologian, Gregory of Nyssa, "Mystical Theology", Episode 17, Prof. C. Veniamin
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Series: Mystical Theology
Episode 17: The Cappadocian Fathers, Part 2: Basil the Great, Gregory the Theologian, Gregory of Nyssa, "Mystical Theology", Episode 17, Prof. C. Veniamin
Episode 17 of our “Mystical Theology” series is deeper probe in to the trinitarian theology of the great Cappadocian Fathers: Basil the Great, Gregory the Theologian, Gregory of Nyssa, and also Amphilochius of Iconium.
Following a reading of Letter 234 on the Essence–Energies distinction, we explore the various ways that the Cappadocians affirm the oneness of God the Holy Trinity, in preparation for their seminal teaching of the Monarchy of God the Father, and the mystery of the Threeness of God.
Themes covered in this podcast are listed in the Timestamps below.
Q&As related to Episode 17 available in The Professor’s Blog: https://mountthabor.com/blogs/the-professors-blog
Recommended background reading: Christopher Veniamin, ed., Saint Gregory Palamas: The Homilies (Dalton PA: 2022); The Orthodox Understanding of Salvation: "Theosis" in Scripture and Tradition (2016); and Metropolitan Hierotheos Vlachos, Empirical Dogmatics of the Orthodox Catholic Church: According to the Spoken Teaching of Father John Romanides, Vol. 1 (2012), Vol. 2 (repr. ed. 2020).
Join the Mount Thabor Academy Podcasts and help us to bring podcasts on Orthodox theology and the spiritual life to the wider community.
If you enjoy our podcast, consider supporting our The Mount Thabor Academy Patreon page, to unlock exclusive, member-only content.
Print Books by MOUNT THABOR PUBLISHING
eBooks Amazon Kindle
Contact us: info@mountthabor.com
Dr. Christopher Veniamin D.Phil. (Oxon.)
The Nature of God and Language
Speaker 1I should like to begin by reminding you that the Unomians had a curious view of language , influenced perhaps by a basically platonic metaphysic , which regarded the names of things as denoting and revealing their very essence . Furthermore , they divided names into two categories those which are the product of divine revelation , the highest of which was the term agenidos , meaning unbegotten or ingenurate , and those which are given to us by convention , that is to say names which are the product of the human mind . So we said that we could see how the Anamoian position that the Son is unlike the Father goes hand in hand with a particular view of language and with the view that we can comprehend the very essence of God , the Father . So what do the Cappadocian Fathers say in response to this ? Well , first and foremost , they insist that it's impossible to grasp God's essence with the human mind . They insist on the impossibility of describing the essence of God in human language . And St Basil says characteristically , every theological expression fails to convey properly the meaning of the speaker .
Speaker 1Our intellect is weak , says St Basil , and our tongue is yet more inadequate . That's from his epistle number seven . So we cannot express in words all that we think , and our thought cannot grasp the true meaning of God ? He who makes his own intellect , says Basil . The measure of reality does not reflect that . It is easier to measure the whole ocean with a tiny cup than to grasp the ineffable greatness of God with the human mind . Interpretation of Psalm 115 , patrologia Graeca , volume 30 , column 105c . So there's a radical disparity between our intellectual powers and the transcendent being of God . We do not know , says Basil , the true nature , the inner essence of our own soul , or even of the ground on which our feet stand . There's always , even in the things nearest and most familiar to us , an unknowable aspect , an unknowable element . How much less can we know than the inner essence of the unknowable God ? All theological discourse is fundamentally inadequate . There are no descriptions or definitions of the divine nature . There are only symbols , pointers , signposts . But of course Saint Basil didn't think that God is totally unknowable . And he makes a celebrated distinction in Epistle 234 , a distinction between the essence and energies of God , between the usia and energaia . And this has a long history in Christianity . We know our God from his energies , says Basil at Epistle 234, . It's preserved in various places . One of them is in this book called Documents in Early Christian Thought , the editors being Maurice Wiles and Mark Santer . Maurice Wiles was a Unomian professor at Oxford when I was there as a PhD student and it was very interesting indeed to follow a series of lectures on Arianism given by an Arian . So let's read a little bit from Saint Basil's letter 234 , because I just want to give you a little bit of a sense of the feel of Saint Basil as well as what he says .
Speaker 1Very often we analyze and break things down and we present them systematically , but it's also helpful to see how the fathers write , how they speak on these issues , and often it is the case that things become much more clearer when you do that , when you go to the sources . Secondary sources can complicate things . So letter 234 in St Basil's collection of epistles Do you worship what you know or what you do not know ? It's a quotation from Eunomius . If we answer says Basil , we worship something that we know , they retort immediately what is the essence of what you worship ? Then ? If we admit that we do not know its essence , they turn around and say then you worship what you do not know . Turn round and say then you worship what you do not know . Our answer to this is that the word to know has a variety of meanings , for what we say we know is God's greatness , his power , his wisdom , his goodness , his providential care for us and the justice of His judgment , but not His actual essence . Their question is thus captious .
Speaker 1To deny that one knows the essence of God is not to admit that one has no knowledge of Him . One has no knowledge of him . The many attributes that we have just enumerated provide a basis on which we form our conception of God . But God is simple , we are then told , and so every one of the attributes which you have enumerated as knowable must refer to his essence . That argument is sophistry , and the absurdities it involves are innumerable . All these attributes which we have enumerated , do they , all of them , denote one single essence ? Is his attribute of inspiring awe identical with his mercy , with his justice , or with his creative power ? Is his foreknowledge identical with his power to reward or to punish , or is his majesty with his providence ? And does the mention of any one of those attributes disclose his nature ?
Speaker 1Now , if they say that it does , they should not be asking us whether we know God's essence . They should be inquiring whether we know God as awe-inspiring , as just or as merciful , and these are things which we confess that we do know . If , on the other hand , they say that God's essence is something different from these attributes , different from these attributes , they must not produce spurious arguments against us on the basis of the simplicity of that essence , for in that case they have themselves admitted that his essence is something different from every one of his attributes . His activities are various , but his essence is simple . Our position is that it is from his activities that we come to know our God , while we do not claim to come anywhere near his actual essence , for his activities reach down to us , but his essence remains inaccessible . Activities , as you can see already , is the word that the translators here use for energies .
Speaker 1But they say if you are ignorant of his essence , you are ignorant of him . Your answer to this must be If you say you know his essence , you have no knowledge of him . A man who has been bitten by a mad dog may see the dog on his plate , but in fact he sees no more than the healthy see , and he is to be pitied for thinking he can see what he cannot see . You must not admire him for his assertion , but pity him for his derangement . So recognize the voice of the mockers in the words , of the mockers in the words .
Speaker 1If you are ignorant of the essence , you are worshipping what you do not know . That God exists I do know , but what his essence is I regard as beyond my understanding . How then , am I saved by faith ? Faith is sufficient for the knowledge that God is not of what he is and of the fact that he rewards those who seek him . So knowledge of the divine essence consists in the perception of his incomprehensibility . What we worship is not that of which we comprehend the essence , but that of which we comprehend that the essence exists . And we can put the following counter question no man has seen God at any time . The only begotten son , he who is in the bosom of the Father , has revealed him . What is it of the Father that the Only Begotten has revealed ? His essence or his power ? If it is his power , then we know as much as he has revealed to us .
Speaker 1And the last few lines go on as follows when did Abraham worship ? Was it not when he believed ? And when did he believe ? Was it not when he was called ? Where , in this case , is there any scriptural testimony to Abraham's having comprehended ? And the disciples , when did they worship him , was it not when they saw creation subject to him , from the obedience of the sea and the winds to him , they came to the knowledge of his divinity .
Speaker 1Accordingly , his activities are the basis of knowledge and knowledge is the basis of worship . Do you believe that I can do this ? I believe Lord and he worshipped him . Thus , worship is consequent on faith and faith is grounded on God's power . You say that the believer has knowledge as well as faith . Yes , but his knowledge has the same basis as his faith and , conversely , faith has the same basis as knowledge . We know God from his power . Thus we believe in him , of whom we have knowledge , and we worship him in whom we have faith . That's how Saint Basil talks about this question what is knowable in God ? So the essence means God is transcendent , the energies , that God is imminent . The essence refers to God as unknowable . The energies refer to God as revealed , as revealed . So we do know something of God , but we never know God exhaustively . That needs to be qualified too . But behind this dispute between the Cappadocians and the Arians lies not only two different views of the status of the sun , but two different views of the nature of God and the limits to our knowledge of God . When studying the Cappadocian's doctrine of the Trinity , we note that they are concerned to affirm the mystical aspect of God .
Personal and Mutual Divinity in God
Speaker 1What I would like to do next is talk about how the Cappadocians , in addition to the Homo Ocean , emphasize the mystery of the oneness of God , the Holy Trinity , and then I want to talk about the diversity in God , god's threeness . But first I want to begin with a quotation from St Gregory the Theologian , from his famous Oration 39 on the holy lights , or on holy epiphany , or on holy baptism . Oration 39 , where St Gregory says when I speak of God , you must be illumined at once by one flash of lightning and by three , three in properties , in hypostases , in persons , if any prefer so to call them . For we will not quarrel about words so long as the syllables convey the same meaning , but one in respect of usia essence , that is , of the Godhead . For God , if I may so express it , is indivisibly divided and dividedly conjoined . St Gregory the theologian loves to use these dialectical paradoxes indivisibly divided and dividedly conjoined to express the mystery of God . As Metropolitan Callistos would say , you've got to stretch language beyond its natural abilities , and that's what the fathers do and that's what St Gregory the theologian is doing here . You must be illumined at once by one flash of lightning and by three .
Speaker 1Notice that there is no superiority . The oneness of God does not stand above the threeness of God . The threeness of God does not stand above the oneness of God . That is so important . It's so important to absorb , because we live in a culture which is imbued with , is imbued with , even though it's unspoken most of the time , even though people are not theologically cultivated . When you say the Holy Trinity , in the minds of most people and you see this with children especially I remember at school there was this idea that there's the Holy Trinity and then there's God . Somehow God stands above the Holy Trinity . And so what Saint Gregory the theologian is saying here is very important . There is no distinction . God is the holy trinity , the holy trinity is god . We're speaking of one being . We've said this before . It bears repeating . The threeness and unity of god are equally present , they're simultaneous . We are not to think of God first as three and then as one . We're not to think of him as one and then as three . We have to think of him as three in one at once , and that is very important indeed indeed .
Speaker 1Now there's a history to the language of hypostasis and I really don't want to go into that too deeply here . It's not necessary , I think . But one thing I think is of interest worth underlining is that Saint Athanasius himself , in council at Alexandria , which took place in 362 , long after Nicaea Saint Athanasius was the chair of that council In this council , the Fathers allowed for greater flexibility . Namely , they said that both one hypostasis language and three hypostasis language is acceptable . I think that's interesting to note that as early as 362 , st Athanasius was saying that , like St Gregory the theologian , if what you mean is orthodox when you use one hypostasis language , that's fine , because at that time hypostasis was still synonymous with usia and it was beginning to change . So you can see from the decision of this council that three-hypostasis language was also acceptable when used correctly , when used correctly , and so , as I said , that's worth mentioning .
Speaker 1Yeah , let's go to the unity of God and the ways by which the Cappadocians describe that unity . First of all , very briefly , saint Basil the Great and the other Cppadocians argued that arithmetic is inapplicable . It doesn't help when it comes to the mystery of the holy trinity . Arithmetic is not going to help you . We do not count by addition , says saint basil , passing from the one to the many , by increase . We do not say one , two , three or first , second , third .
Speaker 1When it comes to God , that just doesn't apply . Three youths , he says Peter , james and John . Each is a man and together they're three men . But we can't say that about God , father , son and Holy Spirit . Each is God , yes , but together , father , son and Holy Spirit , are not three gods , they are one God . And so in the case of humans , we say one plus one plus one equals three . But in the case of Father , one plus one equals three . But in the case of Father , son and Holy Spirit , one plus one plus one equals one . So the three divine persons cannot be added together in the way that three human beings can .
Speaker 1And , as Metropolitan Callistos explains , what Saint Basil is implying here is that God is not quantifiable . The divine essence is not shared out between the three persons . The whole Godhead , the entire divinity exists undivided and undiminished in each of the three divine hypostases . So there's the first point in which the Cappadocians say God is different from humans as regards union . Secondly and here the Cappadocians are developing the idea of kynonia , of communion they describe God in terms of mutual indwelling , of co-inherence . Take , for example , gregory of Nyssa , again from the letter 38 in the Brazilian collection on the difference between osia and hypostasis , where he says all that is the father's abides in the Father . He has in his turn the whole Father abiding in himself . All that is the Father's is seen in the Son and all that is the Son's belongs also to the Father . Take a look at the Gospel , according to St John , chapter 17 , that they all may be one , as thou , father , art in me and I in thee , and so on , father , son and , yes , holy Spirit , spirit indwell one another totally . Each is totally interpenetrated by the other two . Metropolitan Callistos used to say we each have secrets from one another , but the members of the Trinity don't have secrets from one another . But the members of the Trinity don't have secrets from one another . There's a total openness between the three persons of the Trinity .
Speaker 1So here the Cappadocians are developing the idea of God as communion , and there's a later technical term , perichoresis , developing the idea of God as communion , and there's a later technical term , perichoresis , perichoresis . It's not one that is used by the Cappadocians at this point . Originally the term was used by St Maximus the Confessor , in reference to the two natures in Christ . And later , when Saint John Damascene was writing his exact exposition of the Orthodox faith , he applied the term perichoresis to the mystery of the Holy Trinity , the person's hypostases of the Holy Trinity . So , perichoro , literally a movement in a circle in which each makes space for the other . Each person , or hypostasis in this case , contains the other . Some people relate perichorisis to the word horos , which means a dance , which is a nice idea , as Metropolitan Callisto says , but it's not correct .
Speaker 1So there's the second way interpenetration , co-inherence , perichoresis , second way by which the Cappadocian fathers emphasized the unity of God , the Holy Trinity . So we come now to a third way . As a result of this mutual indwelling , the three divine hypostases , father , son and Holy Spirit , share a single energy and a single will and , as Metropolitan Callistos points out here clearly , the unity of the three divine persons is far stronger than the unity between three humans . Three humans may cooperate with one another , but each has his or her own will and own energy and they can choose to end their cooperation and act apart . But in the case of God , in the actions of the three divine hypostases towards the world , none of the three ever acts on his own . Apart from the other two , all the divine actions towards the world are shared .
Speaker 1Let me and my translation is from Hardy and Richardson , christology of the Later Fathers , pages 261 to 262 . Now in this work to Ablabius that there are not three gods . St Gregory of Nyssa says we do not learn that the Father does something on his own in which the Son does not cooperate , or again , that the Son acts on his own without the Spirit . Rather , does every energy which extends from God to creation have its origin from the Father , proceed through the Son and reach its completion in the Holy Spirit ? Quote unquote . In the Holy Spirit ? Quote unquote .
Speaker 1So here we have the classic schema of the divine economy ek tu patros . From the Father , dia tu iu . Through the Son , en agio pnevmati . In the Holy Spirit , everything reaches its completion , its perfection and so on . So the divine unity is manifested through the single action or energy , or operation of the three divine hypostases , which is at the same time the expression of their single will .
The Unity of the Trinity
Speaker 1We've said before how do we know the will of God ? We know the will of God by what he does . Through his actions , his deeds , his will is revealed . So every energy which extends from god to creation , has its origin from the father , proceed through the son and reaches its completion in the holy spirit . So here's the third way in which the unity is underlined . And so we come to the fourth way , which is probably the most difficult to understand . I'm referring to the monarchy of the father . Y monarquía tu patros . And I think that it's probably a good place for us to pause . Please subscribe to our channel and share with your friends . Click on the join button below our video and become a friend or reader of the mount tabor academy . Support our drive to introduce the theology and spiritual life of the orthodox church to the wider community .